**
In a significant policy shift, Health Secretary Wes Streeting has appointed Donna Ockenden to head an independent inquiry into ongoing maternity failings at Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust. This decision follows persistent advocacy from bereaved families and affected individuals, illuminating the systemic issues within the trust’s maternity and neonatal services. The inquiry aims to address what has been described as “repeated maternity failures,” with an urgent focus on improving safety and quality in these critical healthcare areas.
The Context of Maternity Failures
The inquiry comes amid alarming findings that suggest preventable tragedies have occurred within the maternity units at Leeds General Infirmary and St James’s University Hospital. A BBC investigation revealed that at least 56 babies and two mothers may have died due to lapses in care over a five-year period. These distressing revelations have catalysed calls for accountability and reform, prompting Streeting to announce an inquiry in October 2025 to explore the factors that contributed to these catastrophic outcomes.
Initially, Streeting indicated that Ockenden would not lead the inquiry, a decision that drew widespread criticism. In response to mounting pressure from families and MPs, he reconsidered, ultimately designating Ockenden as the chair. This change marks a pivotal moment in the inquiry’s trajectory, reflecting the importance of public and familial trust in the process.
Families’ Response and Ockenden’s Vision
Families directly affected by the maternity failures expressed relief at Ockenden’s appointment. Amarjit Kaur Matharoo, who tragically lost her daughter Asees during childbirth, stated, “It had been a really exhausting, long road to get to a point where we’ve got a chair that we all agree upon.” Her sentiment is echoed by other parents, such as Lauren Caulfield, who views the appointment as a means of honouring her stillborn daughter, Grace. “This is the best gift I could give her,” she remarked, underscoring the emotional weight of this inquiry.
Ockenden, who has extensive experience in maternity care and is currently overseeing a similar review in Nottingham, assured families that her independent review team would consist of professionals from diverse specialties, including doctors, nurses, and midwives. “The purpose of the review is to provide families with trusted answers,” she emphasised. She also highlighted the importance of enhancing the safety and quality of maternity services, indicating that regular learning meetings will be integral to the process.
The Path Forward for Maternity Services
While the full terms of reference for the Leeds inquiry are still under discussion, the government anticipates that it will encompass a review of stillbirths, neonatal deaths, and serious injuries dating from 1 January 2011 to 31 December 2025. Notably, the inquiry will operate on an opt-out basis, automatically including cases that meet the criteria unless families choose to exclude them. This approach aims to ensure comprehensive coverage of the issues at hand.
The Care Quality Commission (CQC) previously rated the maternity units as “good”, yet unannounced inspections later downgraded them to “inadequate” due to identified risks of avoidable harm. Concerns over a “blame culture” within the trust have also been raised, which has reportedly discouraged staff from voicing concerns regarding safety and care.
Brendan Brown, Chief Executive of Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, has publicly committed to cooperating fully with Ockenden and her team, pledging transparency in the review process. He expressed regret over the loss and harm experienced by families and reassured current patients that improvements are underway in maternity services.
Why it Matters
The appointment of Donna Ockenden to lead this inquiry is a crucial step towards restoring trust in the maternity services at Leeds Teaching Hospitals. It highlights the power of advocacy from bereaved families, whose voices have often been overlooked in healthcare discussions. As the inquiry progresses, it presents an opportunity not only to address past failings but also to implement systemic changes that could prevent future tragedies. The stakes are high—ensuring that every mother and baby receives the safe, compassionate care they deserve is a fundamental obligation of the health system. In the wake of this inquiry, there is hope for both accountability and significant reform in maternity care across the NHS.
