In a significant move that has sparked dissent within the Labour Party, approximately 50 MPs have rallied against the decision to prevent Andy Burnham from contesting the upcoming Gorton and Denton by-election. The controversy has ignited discussions about party unity, with senior figures urging colleagues to reconsider the implications of sidelining a prominent candidate viewed as Labour’s best hope for victory in the constituency.
Growing Dissent Among Labour MPs
The discontent among Labour MPs comes after a vote by the party’s National Executive Committee (NEC) that blocked Burnham’s candidacy during a meeting held last Sunday. Critics, including the signatories of the letter addressed to Prime Minister Rishi Sunak and the NEC chair, argue that this decision is a “real gift” to the opposition party, Reform UK. Polls suggest that Burnham could significantly enhance Labour’s chances in Gorton and Denton, a seat left vacant following former MP Andrew Gwynne’s resignation due to health issues.
The letter from the MPs underscored their belief that there is “no legitimate reason” for Burnham to be barred from running, urging the NEC to reconsider its stance. Their concerns are amplified by comments from Nigel Farage, leader of Reform UK, who noted that Burnham’s absence boosts his party’s prospects in the by-election, admitting that competing against him would have been a formidable challenge.
The Stakes for Labour
As the political landscape heats up, the by-election is set for February 26. Labour’s internal turmoil comes at a time when Sir Keir Starmer is facing mounting pressure to solidify his leadership and address the party’s declining poll ratings. The decision to block Burnham appears to stem from fears of a potential leadership challenge, as both Starmer and Burnham’s approval ratings have faltered.
While Prime Minister Sunak has justified the decision by arguing that an additional election in Manchester would divert resources from critical local elections, Labour insiders are expressing grave concerns about the potential fallout. Former Labour cabinet minister Louise Haigh warned that the party might deeply regret this exclusion if it leads to an electoral loss, while backbencher Simon Opher labelled the decision an “own goal.”
A Divided Party
With Starmer preparing for a diplomatic trip to China, the scrutiny over his decision to block Burnham is intensifying. During a recent gathering of Labour backbench MPs, questions arose about the implications of this choice. Attorney General Lord Hermer, a close ally of Starmer, encouraged MPs to shift their focus away from internal disputes, asserting that the real battle lies between Labour and Reform UK.
Despite the mounting pressure, Starmer remains resolute, stating that the defining challenge of the time is the contest against Reform UK. Meanwhile, party chair Anna Turley has emphasised the need for Labour to enter the election with an optimistic message.
However, sources have revealed that some party officials privately anticipate a loss in the by-election, fearing that Labour could fall behind not only Reform UK but also the Green Party.
Future Prospects for Burnham
In the wake of his exclusion, Andy Burnham expressed disappointment but has not entirely ruled out a return to Westminster in the future. There are indications that Starmer has offered Burnham support to contest another north-west seat in the 2027 elections, strategically aligning Labour’s ambitions with Burnham’s political trajectory.
Why it Matters
The turmoil within Labour highlights the fragility of party unity amid challenging electoral circumstances. As key figures express their dissatisfaction with leadership decisions, the potential loss of the Gorton and Denton seat could have far-reaching implications for Labour’s standing in British politics. The party’s ability to galvanise support and present a united front could determine its future viability, especially as it navigates a landscape marked by fierce competition from both Reform UK and the Green Party.
