After a 13-year hiatus, the much-anticipated sixth instalment of the Scary Movie franchise has hit cinemas, but early reactions suggest this comeback may not have been worth the wait. With a disappointing 32 per cent rating on Rotten Tomatoes and mixed reviews flooding in, critics are questioning whether the beloved horror spoof series should have stayed dormant.
A Star-Studded Reunion
Bringing together the original Core Four—Marlon Wayans, Shawn Wayans, Anna Faris, and Regina Hall—the film aims to satirise a decade of horror cinema that has emerged since the last film in 2013. The new chapter, simply titled Scary Movie, pokes fun at recent hits like 2019’s *Ma*, 2022’s *M3GAN*, and 2025’s blockbusters *Weapons* and *Sinners*. Yet, despite its promising roster of references and a reunited cast that many fans adore, the film has struggled to resonate with audiences.
Critics Sound Off
As the premiere date of June 5 draws near, feedback from early screenings has been decidedly underwhelming. With a Metacritic score of 37, indicating generally unfavourable reviews, and an average of just 3.0 on Letterboxd, the film seems to have fallen flat. Critics have labelled the plot as predictable, while others have pointed out the reliance on outdated jokes. One user on Rotten Tomatoes lamented, “Scary Movie 2026’s joke success rate is unfortunately on the low side, feeling like maybe 3 or 4 out of every 10 jokes hit the mark.” Another reviewer described it as “a dreadful reboot that stumbles through tired, miserable ideas for comedy.”
The film, which features a 96-minute runtime, has also drawn criticism for its heavy reliance on cinematic in-jokes. A third viewer remarked that the result is “a slow death that drags even at 96 minutes,” indicating that the pacing and content may leave audiences longing for the franchise’s original charm.
The Wayans Speak Out
Marlon Wayans, who co-created the franchise with his brothers, had previously acknowledged the potential for controversy in the film. He expressed a commitment to unfiltered humour, stating, “We just want to make everybody laugh, and we don’t care if you’re sensitive. Even sensitive people need to laugh at themselves.” His insistence on bold comedy may resonate with some viewers, but it appears that the execution has not landed well with critics or audiences alike.
Looking Ahead
As *Scary Movie 6* opens in theatres, the buzz around its lacklustre reception raises questions about the future of the franchise. With the film’s initial reviews suggesting it may not be the revival fans hoped for, the challenge lies ahead for the Wayans and their comedic vision.
Why it Matters
The mixed reception of *Scary Movie 6* highlights a broader trend in the entertainment industry, where nostalgia-driven reboots often struggle to live up to the legacy of their predecessors. In an era where audiences crave innovation alongside familiar faces, the film’s failure to capture the irreverent spirit that made the original series a hit serves as a reminder of the risks involved in resurrecting beloved franchises. As we navigate an ever-evolving cultural landscape, the success or failure of such projects can significantly impact not only box office figures but also the creative direction of future productions.
