Andy Burnham has officially announced his intention to challenge Sir Keir Starmer for the Labour leadership, contingent upon his success in the Makerfield by-election. During a special episode of BBC Question Time, Burnham highlighted the growing competition within the party, referencing Wes Streeting’s apparent leadership ambitions. However, Downing Street promptly dismissed the notion, asserting that the process to challenge the current leader has yet to be initiated.
Polling Boost Ahead of By-Election
Burnham’s prospects in Makerfield are looking promising, as the latest poll indicates he holds a 10-point lead at 49 per cent over his Reform Party rival, Robert Kenyon, who stands at 39 per cent. This constituency, part of Greater Manchester where Burnham currently serves as mayor, has historically leaned towards Brexit, presenting potential challenges ahead. The Reform Party’s strong performance in recent local elections adds another layer of complexity to Burnham’s campaign.
Despite his popularity in the region, Burnham must navigate a landscape that includes a notable Brexit legacy. His ability to convert undecided voters is crucial, especially following the controversial comments made by Nigel Farage regarding the tragic death of Henry Nowak. Burnham pivoted away from allegations of biased policing, instead underscoring his collaborative relationship with Greater Manchester Police’s Chief Constable, Sir Stephen Watson. He emphasised the importance of a neutral police service that serves all community members.
Revisiting Knife Law in Wake of Tragedy
In light of recent events, Burnham suggested that the legal framework surrounding the carrying of knives for religious purposes warrants a thorough review. This comes after Nowak’s death, where the assailant claimed to be carrying the weapon for religious reasons, sparking public debate. When asked if he would support a prohibition on carrying knives for such reasons, Burnham responded cautiously, stating, “I think there’s a case to look at that again… although it needs a very careful debate.”
His comments reflect a growing call for reassessment of policing practices and legal standards, particularly in relation to ethnic minorities. Following the National Police Chiefs’ Council’s announcement to review its guidance, Burnham expressed concern that existing anti-racism approaches may not be effective, signalling a need for reform in police policy.
Kenyon Faces Scrutiny Over Controversial Past
Robert Kenyon, Burnham’s opponent, has not been without controversy. Criticised for his past social media activity, including inflammatory remarks about women and contentious views on Brexit and abortion, Kenyon has struggled to distance himself from accusations of sexism. During the debate, he was confronted by an audience member who expressed a preference for a career politician over a “plumber who is a sexist,” referencing Kenyon’s professional background.
In his defence, Kenyon stated he would not accept the sexist label, insisting that many of his past comments were misinterpreted or taken out of context. He acknowledged past mistakes but refrained from apologising to television presenter Carol Vorderman, despite criticism of his previous online behaviour, which included engaging with a Holocaust denier and sharing inappropriate comments.
Electoral Landscape Ahead
The Survation poll, with a sample size of 518, reveals a fragmented electoral landscape, with Burnham leading comfortably but several candidates vying for a share of the vote. Rebecca Shepherd from Restore Britain stands at 8 per cent, while Sarah Wakefield of the Green Party has 2 per cent, with both the Liberal Democrats and Conservatives trailing at 1 per cent each.
As the Makerfield by-election approaches, the dynamics within Labour and the broader political landscape will be closely scrutinised.
Why it Matters
Burnham’s bid for leadership represents a pivotal moment for the Labour Party, as it grapples with internal divisions and public perception. His campaign is not only about securing a parliamentary seat but also about redefining the party’s direction in a post-Brexit Britain. The outcome of the by-election could significantly influence Labour’s strategy and cohesion moving forward, making it a crucial juncture in British politics.