BBC Under Fire Over Allegations of Missing Evidence in Child Murder Case

Natalie Hughes, Crime Reporter
3 Min Read
⏱️ 3 min read

**

The BBC is facing serious scrutiny following revelations that two whistleblowers alerted the broadcaster to claims made by a prominent true crime author regarding the missing clothing of a child murder victim. Christopher Berry-Dee, who has been linked to multiple allegations of sexual and violent offences, allegedly boasted about possessing the clothes of Karen Hadaway, a girl murdered in 1986. Despite the seriousness of these claims, the BBC’s response has raised questions about its accountability and handling of sensitive information.

Whistleblower Claims and the Missing Clothes

The controversy centres around Berry-Dee, the UK’s best-selling true crime author, who has previously faced arrests and charges related to child sexual abuse but has never been convicted. Reports have emerged that he claimed to have obtained the clothing of Karen Hadaway during the 1990s and 2000s, a significant piece of evidence in a case that has haunted the families involved and the wider community for decades.

Karen Hadaway, along with her friend Nicola Fellows, was killed in a tragic incident known as the Babes in the Woods murders, which took place in Brighton’s Wild Park. The clothes in question were initially secured by journalist Martin Bashir, who was investigating the case for a potential BBC documentary in 1991. However, they mysteriously vanished after being placed in the broadcaster’s possession, prompting a lengthy and unresolved inquiry.

The BBC has faced mounting criticism since it was revealed that the whereabouts of these crucial items have been unknown since 2004, when a police detective requested their return. Despite the corporation’s acknowledgment of its failure, which included a financial settlement to Karen’s mother, the ongoing mystery surrounding the clothing remains a point of contention.

Berry-Dee’s Claims and Past Allegations

In the late 1980s, Berry-Dee actively campaigned for the return of Karen’s clothing to her family, even suggesting that he could facilitate advanced DNA testing. In his book, he recounted a poignant moment where he received the clothes from the Hadaway family, recounting their emotional state at the time. However, it appears these garments were returned to the BBC shortly before being handed over to Bashir in 1991.

Freelance journalist Eileen Fairweather, who was involved in the original investigation, recalled the harrowing details of the clothing’s condition when they were handed over. “They were in a bin liner … inside was a clear plastic evidence bag,” she described, highlighting the visible bloodstains. Fairweather’s efforts to trace the fate of the clothing resumed in 2021, particularly following revelations about Bashir’s unethical practices during his time at the BBC.

Fairweather’s investigation uncovered claims that Berry-Dee had boasted of having possession of the clothes, and she further discovered his troubling

Share This Article
Natalie Hughes is a crime reporter with seven years of experience covering the justice system, from local courts to the Supreme Court. She has built strong relationships with police sources, prosecutors, and defense lawyers, enabling her to break major crime stories. Her long-form investigations into miscarriages of justice have led to case reviews and exonerations.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2026 The Update Desk. All rights reserved.
Terms of Service Privacy Policy