Cortisol Confusion: Why Experts Say You Can Skip the Test and Focus on Stress Management Instead

Catherine Bell, Features Editor
4 Min Read
⏱️ 3 min read

With the conversation around cortisol—the hormone often labelled as the ‘stress hormone’—gaining traction on social media, many people are questioning whether they need to undergo testing or take supplements to manage their levels. However, medical professionals are cautioning against this trend, emphasising that a nuanced approach to stress management is far more beneficial than chasing after elusive hormone fixes.

The Basics of Cortisol: What You Need to Know

Cortisol is a vital hormone produced by the adrenal glands situated above the kidneys. It plays a crucial role in regulating various bodily functions, including metabolism, inflammation, and the immune response. While it is often linked to stress, cortisol naturally fluctuates throughout the day, peaking in the morning and declining by night.

Dr. Roberto Salvatori, an endocrinologist from Johns Hopkins University, pointed out that cortisol levels are finely tuned to our environment and bodily needs, stating, “Our cortisol level is regulated by the minute. It is very sensitive.” Disorders related to cortisol levels, such as Cushing’s syndrome or adrenal insufficiency, are relatively rare and usually require careful medical assessment to diagnose accurately.

The Risks of Self-Diagnosis

As anxiety around cortisol levels grows, many wellness influencers have begun promoting supplements and lifestyle changes to allegedly lower cortisol. However, doctors warn that self-diagnosing and pursuing these remedies can be misleading. Dr. Katie Guttenberg, an endocrinologist at UTHealth Houston, advised against ordering a cortisol test without professional guidance, explaining, “There’s a lot of nuance to interpreting cortisol,” which could lead to unnecessary stress and medical follow-ups.

Misinterpretation is particularly problematic; for instance, women on birth control may receive artificially elevated cortisol results due to the hormonal interplay. Consequently, a single cortisol test is unlikely to yield meaningful insights for most individuals.

Supplements: Proceed with Caution

Despite the popularity of supplements like ashwagandha and magnesium, there is no scientific consensus supporting their efficacy in lowering cortisol levels. Dr. James Findling from the Medical College of Wisconsin voiced his concerns, highlighting the lack of regulation in the supplement industry and the potential health risks associated with unverified products.

“Even with chronic conditions like Cushing’s syndrome, medications must be carefully dosed,” cautioned Dr. Salvatori, warning against the dangers of overcorrection, which could lead to dangerously low cortisol levels.

Embracing Fundamental Stress Management Techniques

Instead of fixating on hormonal imbalances, medical professionals advocate for a return to foundational stress management practices. Eating a balanced diet, ensuring adequate sleep, engaging in regular physical activity, and seeking therapy are all effective strategies.

Dr. Findling succinctly stated, “Nothing new about any of that,” emphasising that these tried-and-true methods can significantly enhance overall well-being, irrespective of cortisol concerns.

Why it Matters

In a world where health misinformation can easily spread, understanding the role of cortisol and the complexities of stress management is crucial. Rather than getting caught up in the latest wellness trends, individuals are encouraged to consult healthcare professionals for personalised advice. By prioritising holistic lifestyle changes, we can foster better mental and physical health, steering clear of unnecessary tests and dubious supplements. Ultimately, the conversation should be about empowering individuals to take charge of their health through informed and sustainable choices.

Share This Article
Catherine Bell is a versatile features editor with expertise in long-form journalism and investigative storytelling. She previously spent eight years at The Sunday Times Magazine, where she commissioned and edited award-winning pieces on social issues and human interest stories. Her own writing has earned recognition from the British Journalism Awards.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2026 The Update Desk. All rights reserved.
Terms of Service Privacy Policy