Why Sleep Tracking Obsession Could Be Sabotaging Your Rest

Emily Watson, Health Editor
7 Min Read
⏱️ 5 min read

The pursuit of perfect sleep has given rise to a troubling trend known as “sleepmaxxing” – an obsessive quest to optimimise every aspect of bedtime through apps, wearables, and elaborate routines. But rather than improving rest, experts warn this fixation may be making sleep problems worse, triggering anxiety and even a condition dubbed “orthosomnia”.

From magnesium supplements to white noise machines and sleep-tracking smartwatches, what was once a natural process has transformed into a high-stakes performance metric. The result? A growing number of people are becoming consumed by their nightly scores, often to their detriment.

The Myth of the Sleep Score

Dr Alanna Hare, a consultant in sleep medicine at the Royal Brompton Hospital in London, is blunt about the reliability of these metrics. “There’s nothing recognised in sleep science that is a ‘sleep score’,” she explains. “That’s just been created by manufacturers.”

Commercial sleep tracking began in 2009 with the Fitbit Classic, and since then, brands like Garmin, Whoop, Apple, Oura, Ultrahuman, and RingConn have embedded sleep analysis into their devices. These gadgets typically break down sleep into stages – time awake, light sleep, deep sleep, and REM – and assign users a numerical rating out of 100.

But Hare cautions that such scores lack scientific validation. “I’ve noticed more patients coming to me with data from various trackers, asking questions about their sleep that are probably contributing to their difficulties,” she says. Even when medical tests come back reassuring, some patients remain convinced something is wrong – a belief that only deepens their restlessness.

Hare acknowledges the value of increased awareness around sleep health but stresses that sleep resists perfectionism. “It’s great that there’s more focus on sleep as part of wellness,” she notes, “but sleep just does not respond well to attempts to perfect it.”

When Data Becomes Distress

A recent lawsuit filed in San Francisco underscores growing concerns over accuracy. The case alleges that Oura rings fail to reliably measure sleep quality and stages, instead relying on AI-generated estimates described as having “a coin flip’s chance of being correct.”

When Data Becomes Distress

In response, Oura stated it “stands behind our science, research and accuracy claims” and emphasized its commitment to transparently communicating what its device measures, estimates, and how users should interpret the data.

Research from the University of Oxford adds weight to these concerns. In a study where participants wore sleep trackers programmed to deliver random – and entirely fictional – sleep scores, those told they had slept poorly reported significantly lower mood, increased fatigue, and reduced alertness the following day. Notably, their actual sleep patterns showed no difference from others in the group.

“The thing with tracking your sleep is that it gives you a number, and this means you have a target,” says Dr Neil Stanley, sleep expert and author of How to Sleep Well. “So you get into this cycle of worrying about your quality or quantity of sleep based on figures.”

Real Lives Disrupted by Digital Metrics

For Jess Hill, a 32-year-old HR professional from London, the impact of sleep tracking became personal. After purchasing a Garmin watch several years ago, she found herself checking her sleep score each morning like clockwork.

“I started to rely on the watch as my Bible for whether I slept well or not,” she tells the BBC. “If I saw a low score, I’d brace myself for a rough day. If it was high, I’d push myself harder – even when I felt tired.”

Hill estimates her obsession lasted three years. It ended earlier this year after one particularly jarring experience: “I was awake for four hours in the night – from 1 AM to 5 AM – yet my watch cheerfully declared it had been ‘great sleep.’ That disconnect finally made me question everything.”

She’s not alone. Across clinics and communities, individuals report similar experiences: chasing ideal sleep metrics while real-world exhaustion mounts, leading to a self-perpetuating loop of stress and poor rest.

Returning to Basics

Fortunately, experts agree that good sleep doesn’t require gadgets or gimmicks. Hare offers straightforward advice rooted in evidence:

Returning to Basics
  • Create a calming environment: Keep the bedroom cool, dark, and quiet – but not obsessively so. “It doesn’t need to be pitch black, exactly 16°C, or totally silent,” she says. “It should be coolish, darkish, and quietish.”
  • Harness natural light: Exposure to bright light in the morning helps regulate the circadian rhythm, aligning the body’s internal clock with day-night cycles.
  • Stay active and nourished: Light exercise and a healthy, Mediterranean-style diet rich in plant foods support overall well-being, including restorative sleep.
  • Keep it simple: Avoid overcomplicating bedtime rituals. “Anything else, you don’t need it,” Hare concludes.
  • Dr Stanley echoes this sentiment, reminding readers that true sleep measurement requires monitoring brain activity – something current consumer devices cannot achieve. Until then, trusting your body’s signals may prove far more effective than any app-generated score.

    Why it Matters

    The rise of sleep-tracking culture reflects broader anxieties about health optimisation in the digital age. While technology promises greater control over our well-being, it risks turning something inherently organic into another source of pressure and dissatisfaction. For many, the pursuit of perfect sleep has become less about rest and more about meeting arbitrary benchmarks – with consequences that ripple through mental health, productivity, and quality of life. As we navigate an increasingly quantified world, reclaiming simplicity and intuition in our approach to sleep might be the most radical act of all.

Share This Article
Emily Watson is an experienced health editor who has spent over a decade reporting on the NHS, public health policy, and medical breakthroughs. She led coverage of the COVID-19 pandemic and has developed deep expertise in healthcare systems and pharmaceutical regulation. Before joining The Update Desk, she was health correspondent for BBC News Online.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2026 The Update Desk. All rights reserved.
Terms of Service Privacy Policy