Prime Minister Andy Burnham has opened the door to a second Scottish independence referendum, telling MPs that a vote could be held if public opinion demonstrates a “clear consensus” for one — a formulation that mirrors the mechanism for a border poll in Northern Ireland.
The remarks, delivered during Prime Minister’s Questions on 9 September, represent a notable rhetorical shift from his position just weeks ago. In July, Burnham told First Minister John Swinney that another referendum was “off limits.” Now, while stressing he sees no current majority for a fresh vote, he has explicitly accepted the principle that sustained public demand would compel consideration.
A Northern Ireland precedent applied to Scotland
Burnham’s comparison to the Good Friday Agreement framework was deliberate. Under that settlement, the Northern Ireland Secretary is obliged to call a border poll “when there is a clear consensus in the country, when public opinion has changed to the point where the call has to be considered.” The Prime Minister told the Commons: “I would say exactly the same situation in Scotland.”
He was responding to SNP MP Chris Law, who pressed him on the democratic mandate for a referendum. Burnham’s reply was careful: “I am not aware that there is a majority of public support for another referendum and until that changes there won’t be one.”
The distinction matters. The Northern Ireland test does not require a sustained majority in every poll, but rather a judgment by the Secretary of State that the political weather has turned. Critics will argue Burnham has imported that ambiguity into the Scottish context — potentially lowering the threshold from the “settled will” language used by previous administrations.
Swinney claims breakthrough
For the Scottish First Minister, the moment was significant. “To go from ‘off limits’ to this is an acceptance of the reality that the people of Scotland will decide their own future — not the UK government,” Swinney said. He described it as the first time since 2014 that a prime minister had “accepted that majority support for a referendum should mean one takes place.”

The SNP leader has been building pressure since May’s Scottish election. Last month, his government published a draft Independence Referendum Bill, demanding the UK government transfer the necessary powers under Section 30 of the Scotland Act. “The world has changed fundamentally since 2014. So has the UK, and so has Scotland,” Swinney argued. “Scotland is ready. The Scottish people are ready. It is time the UK government delivered.”
Downing Street rows back
Within hours, Number 10 insisted nothing had changed. “The PM has been repeatedly clear on this,” a spokesman said. “In his call with the Scottish first minister in his first week, the PM stated upfront that another referendum on independence was off limits and, as our election manifesto makes clear, Labour does not support independence or another referendum.”
The dissonance between the Prime Minister’s public remarks and his office’s briefing is striking. At PMQs, Burnham articulated a conditional pathway. In the lobby, his team described a brick wall. That tension — between a leader acknowledging democratic reality and a party committed to the Union — will define the coming months.
The legal and political landscape
The 2022 Supreme Court ruling remains the hard constraint. The court determined unanimously that the Scottish Parliament cannot legislate for an independence referendum without Westminster’s consent. That judgment, delivered under a Conservative government, binds any UK administration unless legislation changes.

Polls since 2014 have fluctuated. Support for independence peaked above 50% in 2020 and 2021 but has generally hovered in the high 40s since. No pollster has recorded a sustained, clear majority for a referendum itself, let alone for Yes. Burnham’s “clear consensus” test may never be met — but by defining it, he has given the SNP a target to aim for.
Why it Matters
Burnham has not granted a referendum. He has not promised one. But by refusing to rule it out in principle — and by anchoring the decision to public opinion rather than prime ministerial discretion — he has dismantled the “not now, not ever” doctrine that defined his predecessors. The SNP now has a measurable, if contested, benchmark. The Union’s defenders have a new argument to make: not that a referendum is illegitimate, but that the case for one has not been made. The constitutional debate has moved from process to persuasion.
