Nevada election officials have confirmed that the 185 individuals previously flagged by the Department of Homeland Security as non‑citizen voters are in fact U.S. citizens, overturning a claim that threatened to fuel voter‑suppression fears ahead of the 2024 midterm elections. The verification follows a series of contested statements from the federal agency and comes after voters cast their ballots in Henderson, Nevada on 5 November 2024.
The disputed claim and its origins
In July, former President Donald Trump asserted that the Department of Homeland Security had identified a combined 278,000 non‑citizens registered to vote across Nevada, California, Pennsylvania and New Jersey. Subsequent letters from DHS narrowed the scope, indicating that the total could be as high as 278,000, with Nevada potentially containing up to 15,903 such cases. State election officials were then asked to review the records and, in August, DHS officials told staff in the Nevada secretary of state’s office that they had examined the numbers and confirmed only 185 were non‑citizens, while noting that more than 14,000 records remained to be examined.
Nevada’s verification process
State election authorities examined the 185 records transmitted by DHS and, after a thorough cross‑check of their own registers, concluded that every individual was a citizen. Deputy Attorney General Greg Ott communicated this finding in an email, stating, “As for the 185 individuals, our records indicate that they were citizens. You have provided nothing of substance to suggest otherwise.” The email highlighted the lack of transparency surrounding DHS’s methodology. The department has declined to comment on the matter. The email underscored the lack of transparency surrounding DHS’s methodology.

Broader implications for election integrity
The episode is not isolated to Nevada. A report by Votebeat earlier this month highlighted Pennsylvania officials’ push for DHS to provide the basis for its claim of up to 14,576 non‑citizen registrations, and Pennsylvania’s top election official, Al Schmidt, has demanded that DHS explain the basis for its estimate, noting that the agency has conveyed “no high confidence” in that figure. Similar concerns have surfaced in other jurisdictions, raising questions about the reliability of federal data used to scrutinise voter rolls. The lack of transparency in how DHS compiles its lists hampers state officials’ ability to verify claims independently. Consequently, the public may be left questioning the integrity of the electoral system itself.
Why it Matters
The episode illustrates how unsubstantiated claims about non‑citizen voting can be weaponised to justify restrictive legislation and erode confidence in democratic institutions. By confirming that the alleged 185 cases were citizen registrations, Nevada’s officials demonstrate that the real risk lies not in illegal voting but in the spread of misinformation that may influence policy and voter behaviour.

