England’s youngest pupils have emerged as world leaders in social and emotional development, according to a major international study that offers a rare moment of validation for the country’s embattled early years sector. The OECD’s Early Learning and Child Well-being Study places English five-year-olds at the top of the table for social-emotional skills, a finding that ministers are keen to claim as evidence of a system on the mend. Yet beneath the headline figures lies a more complicated picture: persistent attainment gaps, a funding model that critics say entrenches disadvantage, and a private market under scrutiny for excess profits.
A Sure Start legacy endures
The OECD study, while newer and based on a smaller sample than the better-known PISA rankings for 15-year-olds, provides the most comprehensive cross-national snapshot of early childhood development to date. England’s performance on the social-emotional measure — which captures skills such as empathy, trust and the ability to manage emotions — stands in stark contrast to the narrative of crisis that has dominated recent discourse around school readiness.
Sector leaders are quick to trace the roots of this success. The architectural framework underpinning early years provision in England, often overshadowed by the national curriculum debates that consume Westminster, was largely forged during the Sure Start era. That programme, launched by the Labour government at the turn of the millennium, embedded the principle that integrated services — health visiting, parenting support, early education — deliver the best outcomes for the youngest children.
Much of that infrastructure was dismantled during the austerity years that followed 2010. Children’s centres were closed or hollowed out; health visitor numbers fell. That the OECD still finds England’s children thriving suggests the foundations laid two decades ago possess remarkable structural integrity. But experts warn against complacency. The study also measures emergent literacy and numeracy, where England’s performance is merely above average rather than world-leading.
Funding follows demand, not need
The current government has overseen a massive expansion of funded childcare entitlements. Eligible working parents now access 30 hours a week of funded provision for children from nine months old until school age — a policy inherited and extended from the previous administration. The Conservative opposition has pledged to go further, proposing the removal of the £100,000 earnings ceiling that currently caps eligibility. The £700 million cost would, in effect, subsidise childcare for higher-income families.

The architecture of the system matters. Public funding follows parental employment status rather than child need. Families where no parent works — often those facing the deepest disadvantage — remain entitled to only 15 hours for three- and four-year-olds, with no provision for younger children. Meanwhile, private providers, who dominate the market, cluster in affluent areas where parents can afford top-up fees and additional hours. The result is a quiet re-segregation of early education: children who stand to benefit most from high-quality provision are least likely to access it.
Private profits under the microscope
Questions about where public money ends up have intensified. The Competition and Markets Authority recently found that private operators in the children’s social care market were generating excess profits. A parallel investigation into the nursery sector, commissioned by former Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson, is expected to report later this year. Its findings could reshape the debate about whether the current mixed economy of provision serves children or shareholders.
The economics are opaque. Large nursery chains argue that cross-subsidisation — using fees from wealthier parents to support places in poorer areas — is essential to viability. Critics counter that without transparency requirements, there is no way to verify such claims. The government has signalled openness to reform, but any intervention risks destabilising a sector already struggling with recruitment and retention.
Safeguarding and the shadow of abuse
The OECD report acknowledges the “vulnerability” of the earliest years alongside their potential. That vulnerability was laid bare in the most horrific fashion by the Vincent Chan case, in which a nursery worker in London abused toddlers in his care. The scandal prompted a tightening of inspection regimes, with Ofsted moving to more frequent visits and greater emphasis on safeguarding culture.

Sector representatives argue that the regulatory burden has become disproportionate, driving experienced staff out of the profession. Ministers insist that the balance is right. What neither side disputes is that the workforce crisis — low pay, high turnover, insufficient training — undermines both quality and safety. Alan Milburn’s forthcoming review of young people and work is expected to highlight early years as a critical pipeline: not just for children’s development, but for parental labour market participation.
Why it Matters
England’s top ranking in social-emotional development proves that investment in early childhood pays dividends, but the current funding model threatens to calcify inequality by directing the richest resources to the most advantaged families. As the government weighs further expansion against the findings of the nursery profits review, the choices it makes will determine whether the Sure Start legacy becomes a platform for universal opportunity or a relic of a more ambitious era. The evidence is clear: the first five years are a window of opportunity. Policy must decide whether that window opens for every child, or only for those whose parents can afford the key.
