Whitehall Is Still Sidelining Risk Experts When It Matters Most, Spending Watchdog Warns

Emma Richardson, Deputy Political Editor
8 Min Read
⏱️ 6 min read

Government departments are routinely failing to bring risk specialists into major decisions until it is too late for them to shape the outcome, the public spending watchdog has warned, in a report that raises searching questions about Whitehall’s ability to anticipate the next crisis.

The National Audit Office (NAO), publishing its findings on Wednesday, concluded that risk management “is not consistently integrated into leadership, governance and decision-making across government” — despite a threat landscape that now spans pandemics, extreme weather, climate change, fraud and digital crime.

Its intervention lands at an awkward moment for ministers, coming shortly after a Lords committee described Britain as “seriously underprepared” for the emergencies it may soon face.

A profession built, but not yet embedded

The NAO is careful to give credit where it is due. Recent years have seen the foundations of risk management “strengthened”, with the creation of a formal risk profession across the civil service and a broadening of the guidance, training and support offered by the Risk Centre of Excellence at the Treasury.

Yet the watchdog found that this infrastructure has not translated into consistent practice. Capabilities vary markedly between departments, and many public bodies are not making full use of performance data and early-warning indicators that could help them spot threats before they crystallise. The result, the report suggests, is a system in which the quality of foresight depends on where in Whitehall you happen to be sitting.

The NAO pointed to PHP — the open-source scripting language that underpins an estimated 70 per cent of websites worldwide and which recently suffered security vulnerabilities — as an illustration of how technical shocks in far-flung corners of the digital estate can ripple quickly into public service delivery. When risk expertise is patchy, so too is the capacity to respond.

Its central concern is not that departments ignore risk, but that they consult the wrong people at the wrong stage. A survey of risk professionals found that just over half said they were typically involved “either too late to shape major decisions, primarily to check and approve decisions already made, or not at all”.

That is a striking finding. It describes a culture in which specialists are summoned to validate a course of action already chosen, rather than to help choose it.

Leadership engagement ‘inconsistent’

The report also takes aim at the top of the organisation. Engagement from senior leaders was found to be inconsistent, with some affording risk “limited priority” — a posture that increases the likelihood that concerns are overlooked, addressed too late, or that genuine opportunities are missed.

Leadership engagement 'inconsistent'

Oversight across departmental boundaries is another weak point. Government bodies “frequently” lacked the mechanisms needed to manage risk across departments, arm’s-length bodies, suppliers and local government, the NAO said, even as the public sector increasingly depends on complex, interlocking delivery chains.

Gareth Davies, head of the NAO, framed the problem in terms of consequence rather than process. “The last few years have highlighted the scale and complexity of the risks facing government and how quickly they can escalate into crises, with lasting consequences for public services,” he said.

“Whilst it has made good progress, the government must now put risk management at the heart of how it plans, spends and delivers, making sure that senior leaders are equipped to spot vulnerabilities early and to take well-managed risks to improve public services.”

He added: “This will become ever more important as more decisions and public spending are devolved.”

That final point carries particular weight. Devolution disperses authority — and, by extension, disperses the responsibility for getting risk right.

Islands of good practice

The picture is not uniformly bleak. The NAO identified examples of genuine good practice, most notably at the Bank of England, where a transparent “no surprises” culture allowed concerns to be raised during the modernisation of a critical payments system. That approach strengthened both collaboration and shared accountability — precisely the qualities the report finds lacking elsewhere.

The lesson is that the UK does not need to invent a new discipline so much as spread an existing one. Good practice exists; it simply is not travelling.

The NAO’s broader diagnosis is that government’s risk environment has become “more complex and uncertain”. Recent events — the Covid-19 pandemic, geopolitical instability, economic disruption and climate impacts such as wildfires — have exposed weaknesses in the state’s ability to anticipate and respond to risks that cut across departmental lines.

At the same time, the report notes a tension at the heart of current policy: government increasingly expects public bodies to take well-managed risks in pursuit of innovation and better services. That ambition is difficult to reconcile with a culture in which risk professionals are consulted after the fact.

The government has been approached for comment.

Warnings from the upper house

The NAO’s findings echo, and to some degree amplify, concerns raised recently by the Lords National Resilience Committee, which concluded that Britain is “seriously underprepared” for emergencies and threats including cyber attacks and extreme weather.

Warnings from the upper house

The committee warned that limited stockpiles of food and medicine have left the country “dangerously exposed” to disruption in global supply chains, and accused ministers of complacency in the face of “potentially catastrophic risks” as the international environment becomes more turbulent and insecure.

Read together, the two reports describe a state that has professionalised the language of risk without fully embedding its practice — an administration that can identify hazards but struggles to institutionalise the habit of preparing for them.

Why it Matters

Risk management is often dismissed as bureaucratic housekeeping, but the NAO’s report makes the case that it is in fact a question of who holds power over public money and public safety. If specialists are brought in only to rubber-stamp decisions already taken, then the machinery of government is not really managing risk at all — it is absorbing it silently until the bill arrives. That bill tends to be paid in the currency of disrupted services, wasted spending and, in the worst cases, lives. With threats arriving faster and from more directions than at any point in recent memory, the gap between Whitehall’s risk infrastructure and its risk culture is no longer a procedural nicety. It is a vulnerability in its own right.

Share This Article
Emma Richardson brings nine years of political journalism experience to her role as Deputy Political Editor. She specializes in policy analysis, party strategy, and electoral politics, with particular expertise in Labour and trade union affairs. A graduate of Oxford's PPE program, she previously worked at The New Statesman and Channel 4 News.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2026 The Update Desk. All rights reserved.
Terms of Service Privacy Policy