England’s University Watchdog Warns AI Is Letting Students Complete Assessments ‘in Minutes’ — and Regulators Can’t Always Tell

Grace Kim, Education Correspondent
7 Min Read
⏱️ 5 min read

England’s higher education regulator has issued a stark warning that a substantial share of university assessments can be finished by students using artificial intelligence, often within minutes and frequently without anyone on staff noticing. The Office for Students (OfS) said the problem now represents a “significant risk” to the credibility of degrees, and argued that closed-book and practical examinations remain the most dependable ways of testing what students actually know.

The findings land amid a wider government push to hold institutions to account. Under proposals now out for consultation, universities that fail to meet OfS quality standards could be barred from raising tuition fees or have caps placed on their student numbers.

Unsupervised Formats Leave the Door Wide Open

New research from the OfS, carried out with Advance HE — a charity that hands out awards for teaching excellence — draws on the views of 244 higher education staff and 91 students spread across at least 127 universities. Its central conclusion is uncomfortable reading for vice-chancellors.

“A significant proportion of assessments” take place in “unsupervised, non-controlled formats where AI can be accessed by students completing them”, the report states. Many of those tasks, it adds, “can be completed to a high standard using AI tools with limited engagement from students”.

Perhaps more troubling still: the researchers concluded it is “frequently possible” for students to deploy AI “in ways that cannot be reliably detected”.

The category of unsupervised assessment is broad. It covers conventional coursework, but also remote online exams — a format rolled out at scale during the pandemic and never fully wound back. Research from Swansea University published last year indicated that 93 UK universities still use remote online exams in some form.

Josh Fleming, the OfS’s director of strategy and delivery, was careful to acknowledge the upside. There are, he said, “fantastic” examples of institutions grasping the opportunities AI presents. But he argued there should be “far greater use of AI-free assessment”.

“It also presents a generational risk to the system as it stands, threatening to undermine students’ learning and institutions’ ability to assess them,” he said.

Staff surveyed described a sector under strain. Some reported receiving large batches of assignments that looked near-identical to one another, and said they did not believe their institution’s assessments were “fit for purpose”. Others spoke of a “polarised atmosphere” dividing students who embrace AI tools from “conscientious objectors” who avoid them on environmental and other grounds.

Regulator Signals It Will Use Its Levers

The OfS has stopped short of mandating specific assessment methods, but the direction of travel is clear. Its consultation on fee increases and student number caps gives it a financial lever over institutions judged to be falling beneath quality thresholds — a mechanism that could prove far more persuasive than guidance alone.

Regulator Signals It Will Use Its Levers

The research also sets out a principle that universities may find hard to argue with: if an assessment can be completed using AI without the knowledge and skills it is meant to test being demonstrated, “the assessment should be replaced”.

There is an “urgent need”, the report says, to ensure that remote or “non-secure” assessments “maintain their validity despite the availability of AI tools, meaning they effectively assess the knowledge and skills they are designed to measure”.

Kathryn Harrison-Graves, deputy chief executive at Advance HE, said students were asking for “greater clarity about what is expected of them”, while staff were working with “varying levels of confidence and support”. The report stresses that AI literacy — for students, during their studies and beyond — is now a core competence, and notes that some institutions are already communicating clearly about where AI may and may not be used.

Universities Insist Change Is Underway

Universities UK, which speaks for more than 140 institutions, pushed back on the suggestion that the sector is standing still. A spokesperson said universities were “making significant progress” in adapting to AI.

“There is further to go but many have made substantial changes to how they assess students. This includes more in-person exams, presentations, vivas, process-based assessment and assessments that integrate AI in a controlled way,” the spokesperson said.

“Different subjects will require different approaches, and universities should have the flexibility to adopt assessment methods that best support learning outcomes.”

Student representatives, however, used the findings to reopen a longer-running argument about the quality of assessment itself. Lewis Wilson, from the National Union of Students, said AI was threatening “traditional” ways of learning that students and staff “have long said is not fit for purpose” — naming essay questions, handouts and slideshows among them.

“It’s time to get rid of the outdated methods, that have been kept around in the name of tradition, and instead encourage the innovative practice we see across the sector, co-designed with students based on what they want from higher education,” he said.

Why it Matters

A university qualification functions as a public guarantee: that a graduate has acquired a body of knowledge and a set of skills, verified by people qualified to judge them. If assessments can be completed in minutes by a machine, with limited engagement from the student being graded, that guarantee weakens — and it weakens quietly, well before anyone can point to a cohort of underqualified graduates. The risk falls hardest on the conscientious, who do the work and receive the same classification as those who do not, and on employers and professional bodies who treat a degree as evidence of competence. The OfS’s intervention matters less for what it bans than for what it makes visible: that the design of assessment, long treated as an administrative afterthought, is now the front line in the struggle to keep higher education meaningful in the age of generative AI.

Why it Matters
Share This Article
Grace Kim covers education policy, from early years through to higher education and skills training. With a background as a secondary school teacher in Manchester, she brings firsthand classroom experience to her reporting. Her investigations into school funding disparities and academy trust governance have prompted official inquiries and policy reviews.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2026 The Update Desk. All rights reserved.
Terms of Service Privacy Policy