The author of the Cass review has expressed concern that the current draft legislation intended to ban conversion practices is not yet fit for purpose. In an interview on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, Baroness Cass warned that while a ban is “desirable”, the challenge lies in delivering a “workable bill”. She told the parliamentary committee scrutinising the proposal that the existing wording could lead to “serious unintended consequences” for parents of gender‑distressed children and for clinicians working in the field. The government has acknowledged her comments and pledged to take the committee’s evidence seriously as it seeks to “get this ban right”.
Cass’s reservations and the bill’s wording
Baroness Cass, whose 2024 independent review described conversion practices as “abhorrent”, initially backed the government’s draft legislation when it was unveiled in June 2026. At the time she praised the clearer definition of what the practices entail—and what they do not—and said she looked forward to further scrutiny before the measure became law. However, when asked directly whether she still supported the bill in its present form, she replied simply “no”. She highlighted the growing polarisation in the gender‑identity debate, arguing that the law could be misused in ways its drafters never intended. The current definition requires proof of “serious harm to the individual’s physical or mental health, or serious alarm or distress … which has a substantial adverse effect on their usual day‑to‑day activities”. In Cass’s view, this language leaves the door open for “vexatious” complaints that could expose therapists to prosecution, even when their interventions are professionally appropriate. “Therapeutic interactions can be distressing and often are because you’re discussing quite sensitive issues,” she explained. “If a young person comes away feeling upset, distressed, angry, that might be the result of a quite appropriate therapeutic intervention but still could be judged as poor professional practice.”
The author also pointed to the “chilling effect” that the prospect of complaint or prosecution could have on staff at the new NHS Gender Dysphoria Clinics. Professionals fear that even unfounded complaints could damage careers and deter them from providing necessary support. Moreover, the scope of the bill could inadvertently criminalise parental actions such as withholding money if a child purchases a “breast binder or hormones”. Such everyday decisions, argued Cass, might be interpreted as falling under the ban, creating a fraught environment for families already navigating complex health choices.
Impact on families and professionals
The potential reach of the draft legislation has sparked alarm among a broad spectrum of stakeholders. For parents, the line between protecting a child from harmful practices and restricting legitimate gender‑affirming choices can be thin. Baroness Cass warned that the bill’s broad wording could capture well‑meaning parental discipline, turning routine family disputes into criminal matters. This, she suggested, could exacerbate the distress experienced by families already under pressure.

Clinicians working with gender‑distressed young people share these concerns. The British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy has joined other professional bodies in urging a more precise legislative framework. They argue that therapeutic processes often involve confronting difficult emotions, and that distress alone should not be equated with conversion practice. The fear of prosecution, they say, could lead to defensive practice, where clinicians avoid necessary interventions for fear of legal repercussions.
Government response and next steps
A government spokesperson responded to Baroness Cass’s remarks by welcoming her input and reaffirming the commitment to “get this ban right”. The statement emphasised that the draft bill is part of a pre‑legislative scrutiny process designed to incorporate the widest possible range of expert opinion. Officials indicated that the committee’s hearings, which continue, will shape the final wording of the legislation. They also reiterated the bill’s overarching aim: to protect LGBT people in England and Wales from practices intended to alter sexual orientation or gender identity, a protection that has been delayed for nearly a decade.
Support for the bill remains strong among several LGBT charities, notably Stonewall, which argues that a clear legal prohibition is essential to safeguard vulnerable individuals. The charity stresses that the current draft, despite its flaws, represents a critical step forward and should be refined rather than abandoned. The government’s willingness to listen to concerns from both campaigners and professionals is seen as a positive sign that the final version will be both robust and balanced.
Why it Matters
The debate over the draft conversion practices bill sits at the intersection of two deeply held societal values: the protection of LGBT people from abusive interventions and the preservation of professional and parental autonomy in sensitive health matters. Baroness Cass’s critique forces policymakers to confront the practical realities of drafting legislation that is both protective and precise. If the law is too vague, it risks ensnaring legitimate therapeutic work and family decisions, potentially harming the very individuals it intends to shield. Conversely, if it is too narrow, it may fail to deliver the safeguards that campaigners have long demanded. The outcome will set a precedent for how the UK balances individual rights, professional judgment, and family authority in an increasingly complex landscape of gender identity and sexual orientation. The stakes are high, not only for current practitioners and families but also for the broader commitment to equality and human rights in British law.

