In a significant move reflecting heightened sensitivities surrounding hate speech, the Queensland government has announced plans to ban the phrases “from the river to the sea” and “globalise the intifada” as part of sweeping new legislation. This announcement comes in the wake of the tragic Bondi terror attack, which resulted in the deaths of 15 individuals during a Hanukkah celebration. Queensland’s Attorney General, Deb Frecklington, confirmed that these phrases will be classified as proscribed under the proposed laws aimed at curbing hate speech.
New Legislation Details
The proposed legislation is set to be introduced in parliament this week and includes severe penalties for those who distribute, display, or recite any of the prohibited phrases with the intent to cause harassment, menace, or offence. Violators could face up to two years in prison, a deterrent aimed at addressing the growing concern over hate speech and public safety. Premier David Crisafulli indicated that these reforms are a considered response to rising tensions and violence, ensuring that Queensland remains a place of safety for all communities.
Frecklington has stressed the need for such measures, asserting that phrases like “from the river to the sea” have been weaponised to incite hatred against specific communities. “These sayings have no place in Queensland,” she stated, emphasising their potential to provoke violence and division.
Context and Reactions
The phrase “from the river to the sea” has a complex history, often used by pro-Palestinian activists to denote aspirations for Palestinian sovereignty. However, many in the Jewish community view it as a call for the elimination of Israel. This divergence in interpretation has led to heightened tensions, prompting calls for legislative action. The New South Wales parliamentary inquiry recently suggested a similar ban on “globalise the intifada,” but with a focus on its use to incite violence.
In contrast, the Queensland government has opted for a broader approach, seeking to outlaw both phrases outright. The Jewish community has largely welcomed these reforms, with Jason Steinberg, president of the Queensland Jewish Board of Deputies, asserting that they will enhance safety and confidence among Jewish residents. “This bill goes beyond words and delivers real, practical protections for our community and for all people targeted by hate,” he affirmed.
Broader Implications of the Legislation
In addition to the prohibition of specific phrases, the new laws will also introduce penalties for impeding or harassing individuals attending religious services, with a maximum sentence of three years. Moreover, the legislation aims to increase penalties for assaults against those officiating religious ceremonies and expand existing bans on the display of symbols associated with hate groups.
Crisafulli has reiterated that these measures are designed to foster a safer environment for all Queensland residents and are not impulsive reactions to recent events. “We didn’t take a kneejerk reaction,” he noted, indicating that the legislation has been crafted with careful consideration and consultation with various stakeholders, including the Crime and Corruption Commission and the Human Rights Commission.
Why it Matters
This legislative initiative by Queensland represents a pivotal moment in the ongoing struggle against hate speech and anti-Semitism in Australia. By purging divisive slogans from public discourse, the state aims to create a more inclusive and secure environment for all communities. As the discourse surrounding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict continues to evolve, Queensland’s approach may serve as a template for other regions grappling with similar issues, highlighting the delicate balance between free speech and public safety.
