Sir Keir Starmer is under mounting pressure to investigate a controversial probe into journalists commissioned by Labour Together, the think tank that played a pivotal role in his ascent to the leadership of the Labour Party. Foreign Office minister Stephen Doughty has publicly advocated for an inquiry, asserting that transparency is essential in light of the serious allegations raised.
Allegations of Misconduct
A report from The Sunday Times revealed that a 2023 investigation conducted by PR consultancy Apco, which delved into the funding of Labour Together, was shared informally among key Labour figures, including cabinet ministers and advisers. The investigation reportedly contained “deeply personal and false claims” targeting journalist Gabriel Pogrund, notably referencing his Jewish heritage and fabricating details about his personal and professional connections.
Additionally, the report hinted at unsubstantiated claims that emails related to the journalists’ findings may have originated from a hack by the Kremlin targeting the Electoral Commission. These revelations have raised significant concerns regarding the integrity of the Labour Party’s internal practices.
Political Fallout
The controversy has placed further scrutiny on Josh Simons, the government minister who commissioned the report. Simons, a close associate of former Labour Together leader Morgan McSweeney—who recently resigned amid the escalating Mandelson scandal—asserted that he had requested certain information be removed before forwarding the report to the intelligence agency GCHQ. He clarified that no other British journalists were implicated in the documents he received.
Former Labour Chancellor John McDonnell has called for an independent inquiry, emphasizing the unacceptable nature of the allegations if proven true. Fellow Labour MP Karl Turner echoed this sentiment, urging Prime Minister Starmer to engage directly with McDonnell on the issue.
Cross-Party Criticism
Nadhim Zahawi, the former Conservative Chancellor who has since joined Nigel Farage’s Reform UK, has also chimed in, stating that if the roles were reversed, calls for a thorough investigation would be overwhelming. He remarked, “This is a huge story,” highlighting the potential ramifications for the Labour Party.
Doughty reinforced the need for an impartial investigation during an appearance on Times Radio, stating, “It’s only right that if there is an investigation, that’s able to run its course, and that we understand what happened. I want to see a country where journalists are able to do their job without fear or favour.”
Why it Matters
The unfolding situation poses significant implications for the Labour Party’s governance and public perception. As calls for accountability grow louder, the outcome of any potential inquiry could shape the political landscape, influencing not only Starmer’s leadership but also the broader relationship between political entities and the press. In an era where journalistic integrity is paramount, the ramifications of this investigation extend beyond party lines, touching on fundamental democratic principles and the public’s right to information.
