**
Recent statements made by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the Secretary of Health and Human Services, have stirred controversy among psychiatric researchers. He suggested that a Harvard psychiatrist had “cured schizophrenia using keto diets.” Experts, however, have strongly contested these claims, highlighting the need for clarity around the potential benefits of ketogenic diets in mental health treatment.
Clarifying Misunderstandings
Kennedy Jr.’s remarks seem to reference Dr. Christopher Palmer, a psychiatrist at Harvard Medical School. Dr. Palmer has clarified that he has “never once used the word ‘cure’ in my work,” nor has he claimed to have cured any mental illness, including schizophrenia. While he does advocate for the ketogenic diet as a promising treatment option—capable of inducing remission of symptoms—he is careful to underscore the speculative nature of such findings.
Dr. Palmer previously published two case reports in *Schizophrenia Research* involving two women, ages 39 and 82, who experienced long-term schizophrenia. These women adopted a ketogenic diet for other health issues and reported improvements in their schizophrenia symptoms. However, Palmer was quick to point out that these reports are anecdotal and should not be misconstrued as definitive proof of efficacy. “Yes, it’s only two,” he remarked, noting the inherent biases and limitations of case studies.
The Ketogenic Diet: A Potential Ally?
The ketogenic diet, which is high in fats and low in carbohydrates, has garnered attention for its potential neurological benefits. Originating in the 1920s as a treatment for epilepsy, it has seen renewed interest, particularly among paediatricians treating children with drug-resistant epilepsy. Recent research has begun to explore its applications in psychiatric disorders, including schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.
Dr. Palmer highlighted that there are currently around 20 controlled trials assessing the ketogenic diet’s effectiveness across various psychiatric conditions. Traditional medications for schizophrenia and bipolar disorder often come with significant side effects, and preliminary findings suggest that the ketogenic diet might mitigate both the disorders themselves and their associated side effects.
The Science Behind the Diet
The underlying mechanisms of how the ketogenic diet may benefit mental health are still under investigation. Dr. Palmer suggested that mitochondrial dysfunction—a factor in many psychiatric disorders—may play a role. The ketogenic diet alters mitochondrial function by changing the type of fuel the body utilizes, shifting from glucose to fat.
Dr. Deanna Kelly, a psychiatry professor at the University of Maryland, elaborated that achieving ketosis can change how mitochondria operate, potentially leading to improvements in psychiatric symptoms. Concurrently, researchers at the University of Edinburgh are employing brain imaging techniques to better understand how the ketogenic diet affects brain function. Preliminary studies indicate that fluctuations in brain glutamate levels may correlate with symptomatic relief in bipolar disorder, although results remain inconclusive due to small sample sizes.
Challenges and Considerations
Despite the growing interest in the ketogenic diet, several challenges loom large. Adhering to such a restrictive diet can be daunting for many, particularly given its exclusion of staples like rice and bread. Long-term sustainability is a significant concern, as the diet demands high fat intake, which may not always be palatable or affordable for patients.
Sydney Murray, a postdoctoral researcher in Dr. Kelly’s lab, noted that individual variations in dietary needs complicate matters further. There is ongoing research to determine whether “cheat days” or more flexible dietary approaches could be feasible for some individuals without compromising the diet’s effectiveness.
A Call for Balanced Discourse
Dr. Palmer expressed his hope that the ketogenic diet could be a meaningful part of broader conversations about mental health treatment. He voiced frustration over the politicisation of his research, cautioning against dismissing potentially beneficial treatments based on partisan lines. “If we continue in these polarized camps… we’re never going to make progress as a field,” he stated.
Why it Matters
The intersection of diet and mental health represents a burgeoning area of research that could reshape treatment paradigms for mental illnesses. While the ketogenic diet shows promise, it is imperative that discussions surrounding its efficacy remain grounded in scientific evidence and free from political bias. As the medical community continues to investigate these claims, the emphasis should be on fostering informed, evidence-based dialogues that prioritise patient welfare above all else.
