Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has ordered an ethics investigation into Josh Simons, a minister in the Cabinet Office, following allegations that a think tank he previously led commissioned a report examining journalists. The inquiry comes amid growing scrutiny concerning the actions of Labour Together, which played a pivotal role in Sir Keir Starmer’s ascent to the Labour leadership.
Allegations of Impropriety
Labour Together allegedly paid APCO Worldwide £30,000 to delve into the sourcing and funding of a Sunday Times article that raised questions about undeclared donations associated with the think tank ahead of the 2024 elections. The investigation’s findings reportedly included sensitive information about journalist Gabriel Pogrund, including personal beliefs and links to his reporting on the royal family, which was said to align with the interests of Russia’s strategic foreign policy.
Simons, who has previously defended the commission, claimed that APCO had exceeded its brief, introducing what he described as “unnecessary information.” In the wake of these revelations, Labour MPs have urged for a comprehensive and independent probe, citing concerns over Simons’ current position as a minister.
Political Responses and Calls for Transparency
Darren Jones, Chief Secretary to the Prime Minister, addressed the unfolding situation in Parliament, stating that the Cabinet Office’s preliminary investigation had clarified the facts surrounding the allegations. He confirmed that the matter had been referred to Sir Keir Starmer, who has now sought the input of the independent adviser on ministerial standards, Sir Laurie Magnus.
Jones underscored the government’s commitment to press freedom, asserting that journalists should never face intimidation for holding power to account. However, the opposition has raised alarms over the integrity of the investigation, with calls for Simons to be suspended pending the outcome.
Broader Implications for Labour Together
The report, which has yet to be fully disclosed, is said to have been shared with key Labour Party officials and GCHQ, which found no grounds for action. Alex Burghart, the Conservative Shadow Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, described the report as “spurious,” suggesting it was an intentional effort to undermine journalists who reported on Labour Together’s financial irregularities.
Labour MPs, including John McDonnell, have expressed the need for a wider investigation into Labour Together’s practices, rather than solely focusing on Simons’ conduct. McDonnell emphasised the need for transparency, stating, “This does not pass the smell test,” as he labelled the current inquiry a potential “whitewash.”
Why it Matters
This investigation raises crucial questions about the relationship between political funding and media scrutiny in the UK. As public trust in political institutions wanes, the outcome of this inquiry could set significant precedents for accountability and transparency in both government and think tank operations. The implications are profound, as they touch upon the fundamental principles of press freedom and the ethical responsibilities of public officials.
