**
In a significant policy shift, Instagram has announced that it will alert parents when their teenagers repeatedly search for content related to self-harm and suicide. This new feature, set to roll out next week in the UK, US, Australia, and Canada, marks the first proactive step by Meta, Instagram’s parent company, to inform parents about potentially dangerous online behaviour exhibited by their children. However, this initiative has drawn sharp criticism from mental health advocates who argue that it may inadvertently exacerbate the very issues it seeks to address.
New Alerts for Parents
Beginning next week, parents using Instagram’s child supervision tools will receive notifications if their teenage children repeatedly search for terms associated with self-harm or suicide. While Meta has previously focused on blocking harmful content and directing users to external resources, this new approach aims to keep parents informed about concerning online activities.
This feature will initially be available to families in select countries, with plans to extend it globally. Meta asserts that these alerts will be supplemented by expert resources intended to assist parents in navigating sensitive conversations surrounding mental health.
Criticism from Mental Health Advocates
Despite the intentions behind the new alerts, mental health organisations, including the Molly Rose Foundation, have voiced significant concerns. The foundation, established following the tragic death of Molly Russell in 2017, argues that such notifications could do more harm than good. Chief Executive Andy Burrows warned that these alerts might leave parents feeling overwhelmed and ill-equipped to handle the delicate discussions that follow.
Burrows stated, “Every parent would want to know if their child is struggling, but these flimsy notifications will leave parents panicked and ill-prepared to have the sensitive and difficult conversations that will follow.” This sentiment was echoed by Molly Russell’s father, Ian, who questioned the efficacy of such notifications at a moment of crisis.
Acknowledging the Larger Issue
Many advocacy groups assert that Meta’s announcement highlights broader shortcomings in its policies regarding child safety online. Ged Flynn, Chief Executive of Papyrus Prevention of Young Suicide, emphasised that while the alerts are a step forward, they fail to address the underlying issues of harmful content that still permeates Instagram. Flynn stated, “Parents contact us every day to say how worried they are about their children online. They don’t want to be warned after their children search for harmful content; they want preventative measures.”
Leanda Barrington-Leach, Executive Director at the children’s charity 5Rights, echoed these concerns, calling for more robust safety measures that are thoughtfully designed for young users. The call for change is particularly pressing given previous research indicating that Instagram still actively promotes distressing content linked to mental health issues.
Increased Scrutiny on Social Media Platforms
Instagram’s new alert system comes amid increasing scrutiny from regulators and lawmakers worldwide regarding the safety of children on social media. Countries such as Australia have enacted laws prohibiting social media use for individuals under 16, with others like the UK, Spain, and France considering similar legislation. As concerns mount over the mental health implications of social media, companies like Meta face intense pressure to implement more comprehensive safety measures for younger audiences.
In this context, the introduction of parent alerts may be seen as an attempt by Meta to demonstrate its commitment to user safety, even as critics argue that the solutions provided are insufficient and reactive rather than proactive.
Why it Matters
The implications of Instagram’s new policy extend beyond merely notifying parents; they raise critical questions about how social media platforms can best protect vulnerable young users. While increased communication with parents is a positive step, it must be accompanied by a commitment to creating a safer online environment. Ultimately, the responsibility for safeguarding children’s mental health should not rest solely on parents—social media companies must also take a proactive role in ensuring their platforms do not contribute to the very dangers they seek to mitigate.
