Allan Massie, the notable Scottish novelist, journalist, and commentator, has passed away at the age of 87, leaving behind a legacy that challenges the conventional narratives of Scottish literature and politics. Born in colonial Singapore and shaped by a privileged upbringing, Massie’s work and opinions stood apart from many of his contemporaries, resonating with a distinctive voice that embraced both history and the complexities of modern Scottish identity.
A Life Shaped by Contrast
Massie’s life was defined by contrasts: the colonial backdrop of his childhood in Singapore, his elite education at Glenalmond College, and later at the University of Cambridge, all of which set him apart from the working-class authors dominant in the Scottish literary scene. Residing in the picturesque Scottish Borders, he carved out a niche for himself, writing novels that were both accessible and richly layered in the realist tradition. His literary heroes, notably Sir Walter Scott, informed his storytelling style, which often delved into historical contexts, mirroring the grandeur and intricacies of Scottish heritage.
While many of his contemporaries, such as Alasdair Gray and James Kelman, emerged from a different socio-economic background, Massie found success through his engaging narratives set against the backdrop of significant historical epochs. He was particularly adept at weaving tales set in imperial Rome, the Dark Ages, and World War Two, drawing readers in with relatable characters and gripping plots.
A Prolific Journalist and Literary Critic
Massie’s literary prowess was complemented by a prolific career in journalism. For over five decades, he contributed to The Scotsman and various other publications, amassing an impressive portfolio of book reviews, political commentary, and cultural critiques. His dedication to the written word was evident in his output, which David Robinson, a fellow literary critic, estimated to exceed 3,000 book reviews for The Scotsman alone, alongside thousands more for other outlets.
Despite his formidable presence in journalism, Massie was not without controversy. His sharp political insights often ruffled feathers, but he possessed an undeniable generosity of spirit towards fellow authors, regardless of their political leanings. This duality was evident in his friendships, notably with the late William McIlvanney, despite their differing views.
A Complex Political Mind
As a political commentator, Massie was unflinching in his Unionist beliefs, advocating for Scotland’s place within the United Kingdom even as he maintained a deep affection for his homeland. His scepticism towards devolution and the 2014 independence referendum drew both admiration and ire. In a pamphlet published during the referendum, he argued for the Unionist perspective, asserting that a confident Scotland could thrive within the UK—a sentiment that encapsulated his complex relationship with national identity.
Massie’s political engagement was deeply rooted in the ideals of self-confidence and historical continuity, and he often cited the importance of understanding the broader narrative of Scotland’s past. He famously stated, “If you feel the lack of self-confidence, you will vote for independence. If you feel confident of Scotland’s ability to remain Scottish and prosper in the Union, you will agree that we are indeed Better Together and vote ‘no’.”
Embracing the Legacy
Throughout his career, Massie was not just a chronicler of Scottish history but an advocate for its literary heritage. His works, including the fictionalised memoir *The Ragged Lion*, celebrated the life and legacy of Sir Walter Scott, highlighting the importance of preserving Scotland’s literary landmarks, such as Scott’s home at Abbotsford.
His ability to engage readers with profound themes—like the interplay between personal relationships and larger ideological movements—while maintaining a readable style often left him overlooked for prestigious literary awards. Yet, his influence and contributions to literature and journalism remain indelible.
Why it Matters
Allan Massie’s passing marks the end of an era for Scottish literature and political discourse. His unique blend of literary flair and political acumen challenged prevailing narratives and encouraged deeper discussions about identity, history, and the complexities of nationhood. In a landscape that often sidelines conservative voices, Massie’s work stands as a testament to the power of nuanced thought and the importance of diverse perspectives in understanding our shared history. His legacy will undoubtedly continue to inspire future generations of writers and thinkers.
