**
Baroness Valerie Amos, who is spearheading a crucial investigation into NHS maternity services, has indicated that she may recommend a statutory inquiry following alarming findings regarding the treatment of mothers within the healthcare system. Her interim report, based on interviews with 400 families and feedback from over 8,000 individuals, has revealed distressing instances of racism and systemic failures in care. With a final report due in June, the implications of this investigation could significantly impact the future of maternity services in the UK.
Alarming Findings from the Interim Report
The interim report, released on Thursday, has painted a stark picture of the current state of NHS maternity care, describing experiences that many families have found “shocking”. Baroness Amos, in an interview with BBC Radio’s Today programme, expressed her dismay at the testimonies gathered during the investigation, stating, “The experiences have been very difficult to listen to, but all of those families have been very clear that one of the reasons that they have been prepared to talk to us… is because they want to see change.”
The report highlights the urgent need for reform, especially for Black and Asian women who reported facing overt discrimination during their maternity care. This systemic issue has raised significant concerns about the treatment and care provided to vulnerable groups, prompting calls for a more thorough investigation.
The Call for a Statutory Inquiry
In light of the interim report’s findings, there is growing pressure from families and advocacy groups for a statutory public inquiry. Such an inquiry would possess the legal authority to compel witnesses to testify, thereby ensuring greater accountability than the current review process allows. Baroness Amos has not dismissed this possibility, stating, “I haven’t got to the point of what recommendations I will be making. I’m not ruling anything in or out at this stage.”
Anita Jewitt, Head of Medical Negligence at law firm Stewarts, welcomed the Amos review but questioned whether sufficient systemic change could be achieved without the powers of a statutory inquiry. She noted, “When systemic themes around leadership, culture, discrimination, and accountability are being identified across successive reviews… it begs the question should this trigger a statutory public inquiry?”
Legal Implications and Family Experiences
Baroness Amos’s report also addresses complex legal issues surrounding stillbirths, highlighting how current laws can disincentivise thorough investigations. She noted that families often feel their only recourse is to push for a coroner’s inquest, which is complicated by legal definitions surrounding the recording of stillbirths. “There are families that feel very strongly that they have seen a sign of life and yet they have been told there has been no sign of life,” she remarked.
This aspect of the investigation underscores the challenges families face in seeking justice and accountability for tragic outcomes. Baroness Amos has committed to examining these legal frameworks in detail as her investigation progresses.
A History of Recommendations and the Need for Change
The examination of NHS maternity care is not a new endeavour; Baroness Amos highlighted that over the past decade, there have been 748 recommendations from various inquiries into maternity services. Yet, the pace of change has been disappointingly slow. “Time and time again families and staff see the same issues repeated despite numerous reviews and calls for change. This cycle must stop,” she asserted.
The ongoing investigation by Baroness Amos is particularly significant following previous inquiries, such as the one into Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital, which revealed that failures in care contributed to the avoidable deaths of 200 babies. With another investigation led by Donna Ockenden into maternity failures in Nottingham, the need for actionable change within the NHS has never been more pressing.
Why it Matters
The findings of Baroness Amos’s investigation are not just numbers or statistics; they represent the very real experiences of families who have faced harrowing challenges during one of life’s most vulnerable moments. The potential for a statutory inquiry could bring about much-needed accountability and reform within NHS maternity services, ensuring that the voices of those affected lead to meaningful change. For the future of maternal care in the UK, the stakes are high, and the call for justice cannot be ignored.
