In a whirlwind of criticism, Reform UK’s candidate for the Gorton and Denton byelection, Matt Goodwin, has sparked uproar with remarks suggesting women need a “biological reality check” concerning fertility. Uncovered footage from November 2024 shows Goodwin asserting that many British women are delaying motherhood, a statement that has triggered accusations of promoting an oppressive, dystopian vision reminiscent of Margaret Atwood’s *The Handmaid’s Tale*. These comments come shortly after his controversial suggestion that individuals without children should face higher taxes, further igniting public outrage.
The Comments That Stirred Controversy
The incendiary remarks made by Goodwin have attracted significant backlash. In the video, he claims that “many women in Britain are having children much too late in life” and argues for the necessity of educating young girls about these “biological realities.” Critics have been swift to condemn his views as not only tone-deaf but also harmful, suggesting they place undue blame on women for the declining birthrate.
Sarah Owen, chair of the Commons Women and Equalities Committee, expressed her dismay, labelling the comments “deeply offensive” and indicative of a misguided narrative that shifts responsibility for societal issues onto women. “For anyone with fertility issues, like me, who has experienced miscarriage after miscarriage, to say we should be paying more tax for not having children is profoundly distressing,” Owen stated. She highlighted the disrespect shown towards women facing various barriers, including financial constraints and health issues.
Responses from Political Figures
Natalie Fleet, the Labour MP for Bolsover, shared her own story of becoming a mother at 15. She described her experience as a “physically perfect pregnancy and easy birth,” but also acknowledged the tremendous challenges she faced. Fleet admonished Goodwin on social media, asking whether he envisions a future akin to *The Handmaid’s Tale*, a society where women are coerced into early motherhood.
The backlash has not been limited to female politicians. Critics from across the political spectrum have voiced their concerns. Hannah Spencer, the Green Party candidate for the same byelection, pointed out that women are currently grappling with the escalating cost of living and healthcare disparities. “I wish the Reform candidate would focus on real issues rather than seek divisive, simplistic solutions,” she remarked.
Broader Implications of Goodwin’s Remarks
In a podcast appearance with right-wing commentator Jordan Peterson, Goodwin appeared to align with Peterson’s assertion that universities are breeding grounds for “politically correct authoritarianism,” attributing this to a predominance of “childless women.” This line of thinking has been met with fierce criticism, with many arguing that it promotes harmful stereotypes and misconstrues the role of women in academia.
A spokesperson for Reform UK attempted to clarify Goodwin’s position, asserting he did not explicitly call for increased taxes on childless individuals. Instead, they suggested it was time for “a mature debate” about encouraging larger families and supporting British parents. However, this explanation has done little to quell the storm of criticism.
Why it Matters
The reaction to Matt Goodwin’s comments highlights a broader societal concern regarding women’s rights and autonomy. In an era where discussions about gender equality and reproductive rights are paramount, such remarks can undermine years of progress. They not only perpetuate damaging stereotypes but also risk alienating women who may already feel marginalized. The backlash against Goodwin serves as a reminder that dialogue surrounding women’s choices, especially regarding motherhood, must be approached with empathy and respect, not as a means to impose societal obligations.
