Ryan Murphy, the mastermind behind numerous hit series, returns with a new offering that dives into one of America’s most storied romances. However, “Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette” struggles to capture the magic of its subjects, leaving viewers questioning whether this nine-episode saga is a genuine tribute or a drawn-out chore. Premiering on Disney+ on 13 February, the series attempts to chronicle the passionate yet tragic relationship of the iconic couple, but ultimately veers into the realm of monotony.
A Romance Rooted in Celebrity Culture
At the heart of this drama lies the relationship between John F. Kennedy Jr., once hailed as America’s golden boy, and Carolyn Bessette, a stunning figure who became a fashion icon during their time together. Their romance blossomed in the mid-1990s against a backdrop of intense media scrutiny, which only grew following John Jr.’s highly publicised break-up with actress Daryl Hannah. Yet, despite this enticing premise, the series fails to engage with the depth of their connection, instead offering a bland retelling of events.
John F. Kennedy Jr., portrayed by newcomer Paul Anthony Kelly, and Carolyn Bessette, played by Sarah Pidgeon, were often seen as the modern-day equivalent of a royal couple. Their union was marked not only by glamour and style but also by the weight of public expectation and familial legacy. However, this intrigue seems lost in translation, as Murphy’s narrative plods along with a lack of focus, rendering even the most compelling moments dull.
A Dull Dive into Their Lives
The series attempts to paint a picture of the pressures faced by the couple, including the relentless paparazzi and the challenges of fame. Yet, what could have been a gripping exploration of their lives instead becomes a tiresome slog through an excess of detail. Episodes meander through their courtship and marriage, dragging viewers through mundane sequences devoid of emotional resonance.
One particularly tedious subplot involves Carolyn returning multiple bouquets of roses from John Jr. after a tabloid report suggested he might reconcile with Hannah. Such scenes, which should evoke tension or drama, instead risk sending viewers into a stupor. The dialogue often reads like a series of clichés that lack the spark needed to captivate an audience.
The Performances Underwhelming
Despite the star power associated with the figures they portray, the performances leave much to be desired. Sarah Pidgeon manages to inject some life into Carolyn, but even her efforts are hampered by a script that offers little in the way of substance. Paul Anthony Kelly’s portrayal of JFK Jr. is marked by a similar struggle, as he attempts to navigate a character who is both iconic and burdened by expectation.
Moreover, the supporting cast, including Naomi Watts as Jackie Kennedy Onassis, fails to elevate the material. Their portrayals come across as caricatures rather than nuanced depictions, which further detracts from the series’ potential impact. The overall effect is a sense of disconnection, as viewers are left feeling as though they are observing a dull reenactment rather than an authentic portrayal of a couple whose lives were anything but ordinary.
Why it Matters
“Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette” serves as a reminder of the fine line between celebrity fascination and outright tedium. The series highlights the difficulty in capturing the essence of a relationship that, while steeped in tragedy and glamour, requires more than mere surface-level exploration. In an age where storytelling demands engagement and authenticity, this offering stands as a cautionary tale—one that may leave audiences longing for the more vibrant narratives that Murphy is known for. As the series unfolds on Disney+, its ability to resonate with viewers remains in question, particularly for those across the pond who may not share the same reverence for the Kennedy legacy.
