In a remarkable initiative, the public is now invited to vote for one of six talented artists who will transform timber from the illegally felled Sycamore Gap tree into a lasting piece of art. This project follows a call from the National Trust for a “nationally important” commission to honour the tree’s legacy and engage the community in its narrative. The voting, which runs until 28 March, allows individuals to contribute to the decision-making process, with their choices accounting for 30% of the final outcome.
A Controversial Legacy
The Sycamore Gap tree, a beloved landmark nestled along Hadrian’s Wall in Northumberland, was infamously cut down in September 2023 by two men, Daniel Graham and Adam Carruthers, during Storm Agnes. Their act of vandalism ignited a wave of national outrage, leaving many to mourn the loss of a tree that had stood for over a century. Its destruction not only removed a natural monument but also severed a deep-rooted emotional connection shared by countless individuals who visited to celebrate life’s milestones.
Annie Reilly, the public engagement director at the National Trust and chair of the judging panel, expressed the tree’s profound significance: “Over the past two years, we’ve heard extraordinary stories about what the Sycamore Gap tree meant to people – from moments of celebration and milestones to quiet memories of loss, connection, and reflection. It became more than a tree; it became part of the emotional landscape of the nation.”
Six Visions for the Future
The shortlisted artists, whose proposals will be crafted from the tree’s remaining timber, represent a diverse range of creative ideas. Their visions include not only standalone artworks but also community-driven projects aimed at fostering dialogue on climate issues. Notable collaborations consist of Alex Hartley and Tom James from Devon and London, Helix Arts in partnership with George King Architects from the North East, Mary Dalton from Hampshire, non zero one from London, Sam Williams Studio from Sussex, and Trigger from Bristol.
The artwork could take various forms, from sculptural installations to participatory projects that invite personal storytelling and communal remembrance. Some proposals even suggest distributing symbolic carved seeds or creating spaces for collective singing, reinforcing the notion that art can be a medium for healing and connection.
A Community Engagement Initiative
This artistic endeavour is part of a broader public engagement programme responding to the tree’s unlawful felling, supported by Northumberland National Park Authority, Historic England, and the Hadrian’s Wall Partnership. The main section of the trunk has already been installed at the entrance to Northumberland National Park, a poignant reminder of what has been lost.
In the spirit of regeneration, communities across the UK have been encouraged to apply for one of the 49 saplings grown from seeds salvaged from the original tree. These young trees have now taken root in various locations, symbolising hope and continuity for future generations.
How to Vote
Members of the public can cast their votes for their preferred artist by visiting www.nationaltrust.org.uk/sycamore-gap-commission. Each individual can submit up to three votes using a valid email address, making it easy for the community to engage in this significant artistic selection.

Why it Matters
The story of the Sycamore Gap tree transcends the act of its destruction; it has mobilised a community and sparked a national conversation about environmental preservation and cultural heritage. By allowing the public to influence the creation of a new piece of art, this initiative not only honours the memory of a cherished landmark but also reinforces the idea that art can serve as a powerful tool for collective healing and reflection. In an era where nature and culture often collide, this project stands as a testament to resilience and the enduring spirit of community.