**
Maternity services across England are failing numerous families, with an alarming report highlighting critical issues at every phase of the maternity experience. The interim findings by Baroness Amos, commissioned by the government, reveal that entrenched racism, inadequate staffing, and a lack of accountability are among the six significant factors contributing to the crisis. With over 8,000 testimonies collected to date, Baroness Amos has engaged with more than 400 families to gain insight into their experiences, promising decisive action in response to her forthcoming final recommendations, set to be published in June.
Alarming Findings on Care Quality
Baroness Amos addressed the stark contrast in care quality, stating, “I have witnessed bad, poor, good and excellent care co-existing side by side.” Families shared a diverse range of experiences, from exemplary service to distressing failures. The review aims to identify how services can transform from inadequate to outstanding. “There are examples of safe and quality care, but the prevalence of poor care is far too high,” she added, highlighting the emotional toll on families caught in this inconsistent system.
The interim report outlines that racism and discrimination are pervasive within maternity and neonatal services, with specific instances reported by women from various backgrounds. Asian women have been stereotyped as ‘princesses’, implying that they are overly demanding, while Black women have been told they possess “tough skin,” suggesting an ability to withstand pain that disregards their individual needs. Furthermore, Muslim families have expressed concerns about discrimination based on their faith, fearing that voicing issues could lead to even poorer treatment for their infants.
Key Areas of Concern
Baroness Amos has pinpointed six central areas requiring urgent attention:
1. **Capacity Issues**: Many services are under immense pressure, leading to delays in admissions and compromised safety, particularly as community midwives are increasingly utilised in delivery settings.
2. **Interpersonal Relationships**: The report highlights troubling dynamics between team members, including obstetricians and midwives, exacerbated by a culture of racism and bullying that often goes unaddressed by management.
3. **Racial and Social Inequalities**: Persistent structural racism has resulted in significantly worse outcomes for Black and Asian women, as well as those from socioeconomically deprived backgrounds. Discrimination also extends to disabled, Muslim, refugee, and LGBTQ+ families.
4. **Lack of Compassion**: Families reported inadequate support during traumatic events such as baby loss, leading to unnecessary feelings of guilt and compounding the trauma instead of facilitating healing and learning from mistakes.
5. **Dilapidated Facilities**: Many maternity units are operating in outdated buildings, which can hinder clinical care, while bereavement spaces are often insufficient or entirely absent.
6. **Staffing Shortages**: Reports indicate that many maternity units do not have enough staff to provide safe care, raising serious concerns over the quality of service that families receive.
Baroness Amos reiterated that the testimonies from families and staff indicate a widespread failure of maternity and neonatal services in England, a situation that has persisted despite prior warnings and reports.
Calls for Comprehensive Action
The ongoing failures within the maternity system have long been acknowledged, with the BBC documenting the experiences of bereaved families across various NHS Trusts for over a decade. One heartbreaking case involves Orlando Davis, who tragically passed away just 14 days after birth due to staff neglect at Worthing Hospital. His mother, Robyn, attributes the tragedy to a lack of attention to her concerns during labour, while his father, Jonathan, argues there is a cultural disconnect in maternity care, where medical professionals sometimes overlook the mother’s insights into her own body.
The Davis family, part of the campaign group Truth for Our Babies, is advocating for an independent investigation into the maternity services at the University Hospitals Sussex NHS Trust. They believe the Amos review will not be sufficient to ensure the necessary improvements, calling for a statutory inquiry to address systemic issues comprehensively. “What’s happening in these hospitals is just a part of the problem; the regulators must also be scrutinised,” Robyn said, expressing her frustration with the current approach.
Labour MP Michelle Welsh, a vocal advocate for maternity safety, voiced concerns that the Amos review could ultimately prove ineffective if robust measures are not implemented. She has urged the government to undertake significant reforms, including the establishment of a maternity commissioner to oversee improvements. “This inquiry must lead to substantial policies that demonstrate a commitment to enhancing maternity services,” she insisted.
While Health Secretary Wes Streeting previously pledged to form a maternity taskforce to drive improvements, reports have surfaced indicating that this group has yet to be established, raising further doubts about the government’s commitment to reform. Welsh emphasised the urgency of moving forward, stating, “Without this taskforce, we lack the necessary momentum to effect real change.”
Why it Matters
The revelations from this interim report underscore a critical need for systemic reform within England’s maternity services. The findings not only highlight the distressing experiences of countless families but also reveal a healthcare system that has allowed deep-seated issues to persist. As Baroness Amos prepares to release her final recommendations, the hope is that they will catalyse meaningful change, ensuring that future generations of mothers and babies receive the safe, compassionate care they deserve. The stakes are high; every family’s experience in maternity care should be one of trust, safety, and support—not one marked by fear, discrimination, or neglect.
