After a staggering four-decade hiatus, the iconic *Muppet Show* has bounced back onto our screens, celebrating its 50th anniversary with a special episode that promises to evoke fond memories for long-time fans. Featuring beloved characters like Miss Piggy, Kermit the Frog, Gonzo, and Fozzie Bear, this one-off revival has attracted a star-studded cast, including pop sensation Sabrina Carpenter, comedian Maya Rudolph, and actor Seth Rogen. Released on Wednesday, the show aims to bridge the gap between generations while delivering the trademark silliness that has defined the Muppets for decades.
A Blend of Old and New
Critics have welcomed the return of the Muppets, labelling the special as both “silly” and “joyous.” However, some have raised eyebrows at the new voice of Kermit, now voiced by Matt Vogel, questioning whether this revival will resonate with a fresh audience. Although the show has been updated for a modern audience in 2026, it also features original performers like Dave Goelz, who reprises his roles as Gonzo and Dr. Bunsen Honeydew.
Ben Dowell from *The Times* praised the revival for its nostalgia, noting that it serves as a delightful introduction for older viewers to share with the younger generation. He commended the “deft deployment of slightly risqué jokes” and highlighted a playful spoof of *Bridgerton* featuring Miss Piggy, calling it a “return to basics” that is “all the more joyous for it.” Dowell awarded the show four stars, noting a recurring gag where Carpenter faces legal action for mimicking Miss Piggy’s iconic style, showcasing their amusingly competitive dynamic.
Nostalgia Meets Modernity
Anita Singh of *The Telegraph* echoed Dowell’s sentiments, stating that the fidelity to the original series is “practically unheard of in the world of TV.” Her four-star review reflected on the feelings of “joy and fuzzy nostalgia” evoked by Rogen’s homage to Jim Henson’s classic creation. However, she wondered whether its home on Disney+ would attract a sizeable audience, adding, “But let’s just wallow in nostalgia.”
In contrast, Lucy Mangan from *The Guardian* adopted a more tempered approach in her three-star review. While appreciating the effort put into the revival, she remarked, “You can’t go home again,” suggesting that the essence of the original may be elusive. Mangan found parts of the show lacking in vibrancy, particularly remarking on Kermit’s new voice as “jarringly different.” Yet, colleague Rhik Samadder highlighted the “subversive” essence of the Muppets, sharing that he laughed heartily throughout the 30-minute episode.
Rebecca Nicholson from *The Financial Times* noted that the show takes a slightly different approach from its predecessor, embracing chaos while retaining a family-friendly charm. Her four-star review celebrated moments of delightful absurdity, such as Beaker’s mishap in a science experiment and Gonzo’s outrageous roller-skating antics, calling it a “treat” for viewers.
A Hopeful Future for the Muppets
The buzz around the revival hints at a potential full series, the first since 1981. Kermit, reflecting on the Muppets’ return, quipped, “Maybe we’re a little rusty,” but if the reviews are any indication, fans will likely welcome more Muppet madness with open arms. The *Hollywood Reporter* suggested that while this may not be the best of the Muppet franchise, it strikes a chord with what the Muppets do best—delivering joy and laughter.
James Poniewozik from the *New York Times* encapsulated the sentiment perfectly, remarking that these Muppets feel both nostalgic and relevant, embodying “the Muppets you need right now.” With critics generally favourable, the show has undoubtedly reignited interest in this cherished franchise.
Why it Matters
The revival of *The Muppet Show* serves as more than just a nostalgic trip down memory lane; it represents a significant cultural touchstone that bridges generational divides. As families gather around their screens, sharing laughter and joy, the Muppets remind us of the simple magic of entertainment that transcends time. In an era where chaos often reigns supreme, the Muppets offer a comforting reminder of the laughter, whimsy, and camaraderie that we all need more than ever.
