**
Research conducted by a prominent fertility charity has revealed a troubling trend in England, where nearly 70% of integrated care boards (ICBs) are providing only one round of IVF treatment on the NHS, contrary to official guidance advocating for three. This disparity is leaving many couples grappling with infertility feeling hopeless and unsupported in their family-building journeys.
Significant Shortfall in IVF Provision
Data from the Progress Educational Trust (PET) highlights that 29 out of the 42 ICBs, which manage NHS budgets in local areas, have opted to limit funding to a single cycle of IVF for women under 40 who have struggled to conceive for two years. This cutback has intensified over the past year, as four ICBs reduced their IVF offerings, further exacerbating the situation for couples in need.
Sarah Norcross, director of PET, expressed profound concern regarding the mental and emotional toll this limitation takes on those facing infertility. “Infertility is already incredibly stressful for people, and it puts them under even more pressure, because there is so much riding on whether that one NHS-funded cycle is going to work,” she stated. “For some, that will be their only chance, as private fertility treatments can be prohibitively expensive.”
The Impact of Regional Disparities
The research underscores stark regional differences in service provision. Only two ICBs—NHS North East and North Cumbria, and NHS North East London—adhere to the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidelines, which recommend three full cycles of NHS-funded IVF. Many areas, particularly in the north-west, are left with only one cycle, creating a ‘postcode lottery’ that leaves couples feeling disillusioned and powerless.
Among the 29 ICBs currently offering a single cycle, 19 are only providing partial cycles. In these cases, not all viable embryos created are transferred to the woman, further limiting the chances of conception. Encouragingly, NHS South East London has recently made strides by increasing access from one partial cycle to two full cycles, but this remains an exception rather than the norm.
Falling Fertility Rates and Increasing Need
Statistics reveal a concerning decline in fertility rates across England and Wales, which have dropped to a record low of 1.41 children per woman in 2024. This figure falls below the replacement level of 2.1, indicating a potential long-term demographic challenge for the nation. The NHS estimates that approximately one in seven couples face difficulties in conceiving, highlighting the critical need for accessible fertility treatments.
Health Minister Karin Smyth recently acknowledged the unacceptable variation in NHS-funded fertility services during a parliamentary session. “Access to NHS-funded fertility services varies across the country, which is unacceptable,” she remarked, emphasising the urgency of addressing this issue.
Calls for Systematic Change in Fertility Services
As new NICE fertility guidelines are anticipated this spring, Norcross cautions that simply updating these guidelines may not lead to meaningful change. “Fertility treatment has always been a Cinderella service, often cut or overlooked,” she noted. Despite NICE’s recommendations for three full cycles being in place for over 20 years, they have yet to be consistently implemented across England, unlike in Scotland, where a more comprehensive approach has yielded better outcomes.
Norcross advocates for a centralised commissioning model, similar to Scotland’s, which incorporates phased implementation of treatments to manage service capacity effectively. “It is a tried and tested plan that England could follow,” she asserted, underscoring the need for urgency in reforming fertility services.
A spokesperson from the Department of Health and Social Care acknowledged the existing variances in access to fertility treatment and affirmed their commitment to working with NHS bodies to improve consistency. They reiterated that ICBs are expected to align their commissioning with NICE’s clinical guidelines.
Why it Matters
The limitations on IVF access pose a significant public health concern, as they not only affect couples’ emotional and psychological well-being but also have broader implications for population health and demographics in the UK. With infertility increasingly recognised as a critical health issue, ensuring equitable access to fertility treatments is essential. The current landscape demands immediate attention and action to provide couples with the support they need to realise their dreams of parenthood. It is vital for policymakers to address these disparities, implement robust guidelines, and ensure that every couple has a fair chance at starting a family.
