In a landmark move aimed at reshaping the power dynamics between Westminster and local authorities, Prime Minister Andy Burnham has announced that mayors of city regions in England will receive a share of income tax revenue for the first time. This initiative, part of Burnham’s broader strategy to decentralise authority, seeks to empower local leaders by enabling them to retain a portion of business rates and gain greater control over essential services including housing, transport, and skills development.
A Shift Towards Local Empowerment
Burnham’s announcement marks a significant shift in the fiscal landscape of English governance. The specifics of how much income tax will be allocated to mayors remain unclear, with the Chancellor, John Healey, expected to provide further details in his autumn budget. Critics of the proposal have raised concerns regarding the potential for economically weaker regions to miss out on necessary funding.
“This move is about ensuring that more of the taxes raised in a community stay within that community,” Burnham asserted, reaffirming his commitment to his pledge of “bringing power home” to every corner of the country. The Prime Minister’s determination to decentralise power is evident; the UK currently ranks among the lowest in the G7 for local tax revenue, with only 5.8% collected at a local level, starkly contrasting with countries like France and the US.
The Implications of Devolution
Historically, strategic authority mayors have relied heavily on central government grants for their funding. However, during his tenure as Mayor of Greater Manchester, Burnham consistently advocated for increased local control over tax revenues. His latest proposals signify a pivotal moment in UK governance, potentially ushering in an era where local economies can flourish with funds generated from their own growth.
The timeline for these reforms suggests that English metro mayors could begin retaining revenue from business rates by April 2027, with income tax sharing commencing in April 2028. Despite assurances that existing income tax rates will not change, the exact mechanism for distributing income tax among mayors is still being debated. The think tank Re:State has proposed that mayors receive 2.5p for every pound raised at the basic income tax rate of 20%.
Mixed Reactions from Political Leaders
Responses to Burnham’s proposals have been varied across the political spectrum. Conservative shadow chancellor Sir Mel Stride expressed skepticism, labelling the announcement “very short on detail.” He cautioned that unless Burnham intends to find new funding sources or implement cuts elsewhere, the initiative may not translate into additional financial support for local authorities. Stride’s concerns echo fears that areas with weaker economies could find themselves at a disadvantage, undermining Burnham’s objectives.
Meanwhile, Labour mayors have largely welcomed the devolution of tax revenues. Tracy Brabin, the Labour mayor of West Yorkshire, hailed the initiative as a means for local populations to see tangible benefits from their contributions. “This will enable us to deliver on our ambitious plans including vital improvements to public transport, providing better skills and employment support,” she stated, highlighting the potential for localised economic growth.
Conversely, Conservative mayor Ben Houchen suggested a preference for a tax cut but acknowledged that if income tax revenues are devolved, he would establish a rebate scheme to benefit local residents.
The Road Ahead: Ensuring Fairness in Devolution
As the government navigates the intricacies of these reforms, it is also working on an equalisation system to support areas where tax income is lower. Under a proposed “local first” principle, ministers will be required to justify the retention of powers in Westminster rather than devolving them to local leaders.
These reforms are currently being orchestrated by No 10 North in Manchester, with a comprehensive policy document set to be released alongside the autumn budget. The early weeks of Burnham’s premiership have seen a flurry of policy announcements, including those targeting the cost of living and social care, suggesting a rapid and ambitious agenda.
Why it Matters
Burnham’s plans for tax devolution represent a critical juncture in the UK’s political landscape, challenging the long-standing centralisation of power and revenue. If successfully implemented, these reforms could empower local mayors to drive economic growth in their communities, fostering a sense of ownership and accountability. However, the effectiveness of this initiative hinges on equitable funding and thorough planning, as any oversight could exacerbate existing regional disparities. The stakes are high, and the outcome could redefine the relationship between local and central government in Britain for generations to come.