Andy Burnham, the Prime Minister, has made a compelling case for a written constitution in the UK, linking it to his ambitious devolution agenda aimed at redistributing power and resources across the nation. This call for constitutional reform could signify a tectonic shift in how the UK is governed, addressing long-standing inequalities and centralisation that have characterised British politics for centuries.
A Call for Change
Speaking this weekend, Burnham asserted that his government’s devolution strategy—designed to enhance local governance and fiscal autonomy—reinforces the necessity for a codified constitution. He described the current political framework as “antiquated”, arguing that a new constitutional arrangement is crucial for achieving parity in living standards across regions. “It will increase the case for a constitution because Britain is changing through this,” he stated, emphasising the transformative potential of decentralising power.
As the UK remains one of the few major democracies without a written constitution, Burnham’s proposal comes at a critical juncture. He seeks to establish a framework that works not only for England but also for Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. “In the end, I think it does start to point towards a new constitutional settlement,” he added, positioning his vision of “good growth in every postcode” as more than mere rhetoric.
Decentralisation: A Radical Shift
Burnham’s devolution measures, introduced last week, are being hailed as the most significant departure from the UK’s traditionally centralised governance. Central to this initiative is the plan to empower regional leaders with increased financial control, allowing them to retain a portion of income tax generated in their areas by early 2028. This shift aims to foster economic equality, with wealthier regions like London and Greater Manchester potentially redistributing funds to support less prosperous areas such as Hull and East Yorkshire.
Political analysts are weighing in on what this proposed constitutional framework could entail. Tim Bale, a professor at Queen Mary University of London, remarked that a written constitution would represent a “huge departure” for the UK, typically necessitating a major upheaval or a significant loss of legitimacy for the existing regime. “One of the upsides is that it might better define the competencies of the various levels of government,” he noted, although he cautioned that such a transition would likely be complex and contentious.
The Influence of Germany’s Model
Burnham draws inspiration from Germany’s postwar basic law, the Grundgesetz, which mandates equitable living standards across its states. This model of redistribution is pivotal to Burnham’s vision for the UK, where disparities in wealth and opportunity have persisted under the current system. He argues that the UK’s unwritten constitution has contributed to entrenched inequality, allowing power to be concentrated in Westminster and Whitehall.
“Our failure fully to set out the rules for how the country should be run is one of the principal reasons why Britain is one of the most unequal major countries in the world,” Burnham has previously stated. His perspective highlights a critical flaw in the current governance model: the lack of a clear constitutional framework that delineates the distribution of power and resources.
Challenges Ahead
Despite the momentum behind these proposals, significant hurdles remain. The intricacies of implementing a written constitution alongside ongoing initiatives related to devolution, social care, and public utilities present formidable challenges. Dr Hannah White, chief executive of the Institute for Government, pointed out that adopting a fully codified constitution would necessitate a comprehensive overhaul of the UK’s governmental structure, far exceeding the scope of devolution alone.
The implications of Burnham’s vision extend beyond mere administrative reform; they encompass a profound rethinking of the UK’s identity and governance. As the nation grapples with the realities of a post-Brexit landscape, the call for constitutional reform resonates with an electorate increasingly disillusioned by the status quo.
Why it Matters
Burnham’s advocacy for a written constitution is not just a political manoeuvre; it represents a pivotal moment in the quest for a fairer, more equitable society in the UK. If successfully implemented, this constitutional reform could redefine the relationship between citizens and the state, fostering a more balanced distribution of power and resources. In an era marked by growing inequality and regional disparity, the push for a codified constitution may well be the catalyst needed to usher in a new era of governance that truly serves all citizens.