Andy Burnham has signalled his willingness to tear up large parts of the benefits system after a long-awaited review called for an entirely new settlement for under-25s, trading lower payments for far more intensive help into work.
Downing Street said the prime minister wanted the 278-page report by former Labour cabinet minister Alan Milburn to be a “watershed moment in how we think about welfare”, as ministers on Tuesday pledged “a new settlement for young people”. The government endorsed the document within hours of its publication and gave its author a new official role — but Mr Burnham now faces pressure to accept the package in full, including projected social security reductions worth £3.6bn a year by 2036.
The review was framed as an answer to the crisis of young people not in education, employment or training — the Neets — which charities and campaign groups have described as a “lost generation” problem.
What the Milburn Review Proposes
The report calls for the health element of Universal Credit and personal independence payments (Pip) to be replaced for young people by a single “youth allowance”, forming what Mr Milburn described as an entirely new benefits system for that age group.
It also proposes devolved Youth Opportunity Services bringing employment, health and careers advice under one roof, with every young person guaranteed a named adviser within 14 days. Employers would be offered payments of between £3,000 and £7,000 for taking on someone who has been Neet for six months, and national insurance contributions for staff aged 21 to 24 would be reduced over five years, with retail and hospitality prioritised.
Education is not left untouched. The review sets a target of raising the proportion of children ready for school by age five from 63 per cent to 90 per cent, alongside a more vocational curriculum intended to prepare pupils for the workplace.
Launching the report, Mr Milburn said: “Britain is at risk of losing a generation of young people, not because they lack talent, not because they lack ambition, not because they do not want to work. This is not a crisis of aspiration; it is a crisis of opportunity.”
He warned that “half measures will not do” because “the scale of the problem is just too big for that”, and cautioned against selecting individual recommendations: “It sort of does fit together as one package.”
The Spending Trade-Off
The arithmetic at the heart of the plan is front-loaded. Ministers would spend £5.8bn by 2036-37 on the new youth opportunity service and associated support, including tax breaks and bonuses for firms that hire young people. In exchange, the Treasury would recoup £3.6bn from the welfare bill and £2.4bn in additional tax revenue — a net saving of £200m that year.

Mr Milburn has demanded a “downpayment” of £500m in the next financial year and insists the package must be a top priority in the spending review. He argued that if legislation passed quickly, welfare savings could begin to materialise before the end of the decade.
He also pressed the prime minister on timing, telling reporters: “Prime Minister Burnham is a half-term prime minister and so he needs to get on with it. And I know that he wants to. So I’m very hopeful indeed.”
Mr Burnham has suggested the philosophy behind the reforms need not stop at 25. “I think the same philosophy could apply right through the age range. What we are doing is creating an approach that is preventative, that supports people where they can prosper. The same applies up the age range,” he told The Times.
Skepticism on the Numbers
Not everyone is persuaded by the projections. The Institute for Fiscal Studies said it was difficult to judge “the plausibility” of some of the modelled effects, including the aim of moving 440,000 young people into work by 2036. The review’s own figures anticipate the Neet rate falling to 7 per cent by that year — slightly short of the stated target.
The IFS also noted that the £3.6bn in annual savings would equal 41 per cent of projected spending on health-related benefits for young people in 2036-37, and warned that “many of those with less severe disabilities would be likely to see large income losses initially”, although this could be offset if they entered employment.
Some critics have also observed that the headline savings shrink to roughly £200m a year once a decade of spending commitments is accounted for.
Work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden told MPs the plan was not a fiscal exercise. “We need a new settlement for young people,” he said. “This new settlement must give people the best chance of higher living standards for the whole of their lives. It must change the equation that sees us spend £25 on the consequences of inactivity for every pound to be spent on opportunity.”
Mr Milburn made a similar point to Labour MPs, arguing that his scheme was designed to move people into work — “a very different argument” from a “fiscal grab”.
Rebels, Backbenchers and the Opposition
The prime minister’s party management problem is real. Labour backbenchers derailed previous attempts by Keir Starmer to reduce the benefits bill, and Mr Burnham said he was “confident” they would support this effort.

Rachael Maskell, a Labour MP who has previously rebelled on welfare, welcomed the “ambition” but cautioned that the “details are yet to be spelt out and therefore I will work with government to ensure they land in the right place.”
The government has so far committed to a new youth opportunities unit reporting directly to the prime minister, with a fuller response promised later this year.
Awkwardly for the review’s author, he conceded that Labour’s own policies had affected the jobs market and “made it harder” for companies to employ young people, warning that a “course correction” was needed after the party’s National Insurance increases.
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch was unsparing: “We don’t need costly government schemes to fix Labour’s own mistakes. We need to stop making it so expensive and risky to hire young people.”
Why it Matters
This is the most consequential attempt yet to rewire the link between welfare and work for a generation of young people who have slipped through the cracks, and it forces a choice that successive governments have avoided: more help, but less money. If the modelling holds, the package could pull hundreds of thousands into employment while reshaping how disability and health benefits are assessed for under-25s; if it does not, the state spends heavily and saves little. Either way, the next spending review will reveal whether Mr Burnham intends to govern as a reformist prime minister or to file another report away.
