The disconnect between paper qualifications and measurable ability has long haunted Canadian immigration policy. A new study from the C.D. Howe Institute lays bare the scale of the problem: immigrants hold university degrees at higher rates than the Canadian-born population, yet their literacy, numeracy and problem-solving scores lag behind at every rung of the educational ladder. For a government preparing to unveil its next three-year admissions plan, the findings amount to a pointed briefing note on the limits of a selection system that still treats a credential as a proxy for competence.
The credential-competence divide
Parisa Mahboubi, the institute’s associate director of research, mined data from the OECD’s Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies (PIAAC), collected between September 2022 and July 2023. The survey tested adults aged 16 to 65 in literacy, numeracy and adaptive problem-solving. The results are stark. Immigrants aged 25 to 65 scored an average of 22 points lower than non-immigrants on the literacy assessment. Even among those whose highest credential is a university degree, half of immigrants languish at the two lowest literacy proficiency levels. The comparable figure for Canadian-born degree holders is 15 per cent.
Put differently, a university-educated immigrant in Canada demonstrates literacy skills on par with a Canadian-born citizen whose formal education ended at secondary school. The gap narrows dramatically — to just four points — when the test language matches the respondent’s home language, whether English or French. That single variable explains a significant portion of the disparity, but it does not erase it.
Express Entry under the microscope
The federal Express Entry system, the primary gateway for economic migrants, awards points for higher education on the assumption that degrees signal stronger skills. Mahboubi’s report challenges that assumption directly. “For immigrants, educational credentials alone may overstate literacy proficiency relative to the same credentials held by non-immigrants,” the study concludes. The implication for policy is immediate: the points grid may need recalibration. Raising the minimum language threshold and weighting advanced official-language proficiency more heavily would align selection criteria with the skills that actually drive labour-market integration.

Immigration Minister Lena Metlege Diab is expected to table the 2025–2027 levels plan within days. The document will set targets for permanent and temporary residents, including international students, and allocate provincial nomination spaces. The Howe Institute’s timing is deliberate. If Ottawa intends to prioritise economic outcomes — as every recent mandate letter has insisted — the selection architecture must distinguish between where a degree was earned and what the holder can actually do.
Foreign credentials, domestic discounts
The labour-market penalty is measurable. Immigrants whose highest credential was obtained abroad earn less and are less likely to occupy high-skill occupations than Canadian-born workers with ostensibly comparable qualifications. The report argues that measured skills — literacy, numeracy, adaptive problem-solving — predict immigrant earnings more reliably than they do for the native-born. When an immigrant’s tested abilities fall short of what their diploma suggests, or when employers discount foreign qualifications, the result is lower individual earnings and forgone productivity for the broader economy.
Overqualification is rampant. Immigrants aged 25 to 65 are employed at roughly the same rate as non-immigrants and are more likely to work in high-skill occupations. Yet they are also significantly more likely to report being overqualified for their current role. That mismatch suggests Canada is systematically underutilising the talent it recruits. Mahboubi posits that the literacy gap itself may be the mechanism: insufficient language proficiency hinders credential recognition and blocks the transfer of professional and technical expertise into the Canadian workplace.
Regional and demographic fault lines
The data reveal sharp variation by region of origin. Immigrants born in Western Europe, North America, or higher-income East Asian economies — Japan, South Korea, Singapore — outperform those from Arab states such as Egypt, Iraq, Jordan and Lebanon, even after controlling for credential location. “Birth region and credential location, therefore, capture distinct information,” the report notes. Gender gaps persist as well: women match men in literacy and adaptive problem-solving but trail by 16 points in numeracy.

Time in Canada matters. Immigrants resident for more than five years score 12 to 15 points higher in adaptive problem-solving than recent arrivals. Skills acquisition continues post-migration, but the starting deficit is large, and the climb is steep. Faster, more consistent credential recognition and better tools for employers to assess foreign qualifications would accelerate that convergence.
Why it Matters
Canada’s immigration system has long sold itself on the promise of human capital: bring the world’s best-educated, and prosperity follows. This study demonstrates that the promise is only as good as the measurement behind it. If Express Entry continues to reward credentials without rigorously verifying the skills they supposedly represent, the country will keep importing talent it cannot deploy — depressing wages for newcomers, frustrating employers, and eroding public confidence in a programme that remains essential to Canada’s demographic and economic future. The next levels plan is the moment to close the gap between paper and performance.
