**
A coalition of bereaved families is calling for a statutory public inquiry into the failings of NHS maternity care, following substantial criticism of a recent report led by Baroness Valerie Amos. These families argue that the report lacks independence and fails to adequately address the systemic issues that have led to avoidable harm and fatalities in maternity services. Their concerns have been amplified by the resignation of a key figure involved in the review, which has raised further questions about its credibility.
Insufficient Independence
The Maternity Safety Alliance has been vocal in its condemnation of the findings presented in Baroness Amos’s report, asserting that it does not meet the necessary standards of impartiality expected of a national inquiry. The Alliance highlighted the involvement of personnel from NHS England and the Health Services Safety Investigations Body (HSSIB) in the investigation team, suggesting that their presence compromises the report’s objectivity.
In their statement, the Alliance described the proposed establishment of a maternity commissioner as “fundamentally dangerous,” arguing that it centralises power in a role that lacks adequate checks and balances. “This person will not be meaningfully independent and will not be able to create real change,” they warned, pointing to the adverse implications this could have for patient safety.
Resignation of Key Inquiry Figure
Adding to the scrutiny surrounding the report, Dr Bill Kirkup, who previously chaired inquiries into maternity tragedies at Morecambe Bay and East Kent, resigned from his advisory role in the review. His departure stemmed from disagreements over the interpretation of “normal birth ideology,” which he believed needed to be more critically examined in relation to patient safety. The Health Service Journal has reported that Dr Kirkup sought a more robust stance on the potential consequences of this ideology, which Lady Amos did not appear willing to embrace.
In her review, Baroness Amos stated that the investigation team found no evidence of “normal birth ideology” being prevalent among the maternity services they reviewed across England. This assertion has drawn scepticism from those advocating for greater accountability in maternity care.
Ongoing Failures in Maternity Care
Critics have pointed out that the Amos report neglects to thoroughly investigate crucial areas of concern within the maternity system. The Maternity Safety Alliance specifically noted that the report does not meaningfully address the roles of regulatory bodies, such as the General Medical Council (GMC) and the Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC), nor does it scrutinise the Care Quality Commission (CQC) in detail.
Furthermore, the report fails to explore significant aspects like post-death care, an issue that emerged in Nottingham’s independent review and prompted serious reconsideration of maternity practices. The Alliance expressed disbelief that the failures outlined in the report are isolated incidents, suggesting instead that they might be indicative of broader systemic issues that remain unexplored.
Tragically, while the inquiry has unfolded, the Alliance claims that an additional 814 babies have died avoidably within NHS maternity services. This statistic underscores the urgency for comprehensive reform and highlights the human cost of inadequate oversight and accountability.
The Call for Accountability
The Maternity Safety Alliance has reiterated the necessity of a statutory public inquiry, stating, “We deserve answers as to why our children were avoidably injured and killed, and why the people responsible for ensuring safe maternity care failed to act even when the problems were known.” The families affected by these tragic events are not seeking mere reassurances; they demand tangible solutions and accountability for the ongoing failures within the maternity system.
Why it Matters
The demand for a statutory public inquiry into NHS maternity services is not merely a response to bureaucratic failures; it represents a profound plea for justice from families who have suffered unimaginable losses. With each avoidable death, the urgency for systemic reform grows more pressing. As the nation grapples with the implications of these findings, it is clear that a thorough examination of maternity care practices is essential—not only to prevent further tragedies but to restore public trust in a system that must be held accountable for the lives it is meant to protect.
