Almost a million young people in Britain are neither working, studying nor training, and on Tuesday Alan Milburn will hand Andy Burnham’s government a stark choice: carry on down the road of state and market failure, or change course sharply. The long-awaited final report on youth and work is expected to recommend controversial cuts to benefits for the under-25s, paired with a legal guarantee of a job or training place. It is a bold bargain — and one that will collapse unless British business agrees to hold up its end.
The plan, which also encompasses reform of education and health provision, would take a decade to deliver. Its underlying principle is one the governing party has long wrestled with: that tightening access to out-of-work benefits is a legitimate lever for pushing people into employment. Milburn makes the case with some force, noting that for every £1 the state spends on job support, £25 is spent on benefits. But the arithmetic of the welfare bill is only part of the story, and the more uncomfortable truths sit with employers.
A Generation Bearing the Brunt
The backdrop is grim. Austerity and the pandemic have cast a long shadow, artificial intelligence is reshaping the labour market, and the cost of living continues to squeeze household budgets — all of it playing out under the unforgiving glare of social media. Unemployment among the under-25s has climbed at its fastest rate since the 2008 financial crisis and now stands at its highest level relative to the all-age total since the early 1990s. Young people account for roughly 40 per cent of all unemployment in Britain.
Clare Lombardelli, deputy governor of the Bank of England, told this publication last week that young people were absorbing the worst of a “low-gear economy”, with employers freezing recruitment amid the war in the Middle East. The phrase is apt. Hiring has stalled, and those at the very start of the ladder are the ones left holding the rungs.
Compounding the problem is a two-decade decline in entry-level positions. The Saturday job is long gone, and the roles that once served as first rungs are precisely those most exposed to automation and AI substitution. It is no coincidence that the parts of Britain with the fewest vacancies also record the highest rates of young people not in education, employment or training. In Rotherham, a young jobseeker faces a sixfold disadvantage in opportunity compared with a peer in the Cotswolds.
The Limits of Welfare Reform
There is a significant flaw in framing this as a benefits problem. Half of all young people who are not in education, employment or training are not claiming benefits at all. Bad jobs and the scarcity of entry-level openings are far more powerful drivers of the crisis than the generosity of the welfare system — a distinction that tends to get lost in the political noise.

Employers, for their part, have a familiar wish list: tax cuts, lighter regulation and restraint on rises in the youth minimum wage. Cost unquestionably matters, and the state could do more to prepare young people for the workplace. But the difficulties run deeper than policy overheads.
When the report lands, corporate Britain will be out in force to demonstrate good faith. Amazon, Marks & Spencer, Shell and Pret a Manger are among the firms that have already spotted the public relations value in showcasing their youth outreach. Few, however, are doing anything close to enough. Running work experience schemes, outreach programmes and the patient support that some recruits need to find their feet costs both time and money — particularly in an unforgiving economic climate. The cost of abstaining is becoming harder to ignore.
Almost half of jobseekers under 25 surveyed by the organisation Youth Employment UK described employers as unsupportive. Accounts of applications disappearing into a void, and of companies demanding prior experience for roles explicitly billed as entry-level, are wearily familiar.
Poor Work, Not Just No Work
Quality matters as much as quantity. Low-paid and insecure employment is rife, most acutely in the areas with the highest rates of young people outside work and study. Over the past quarter of a century, in-work poverty has risen: among working households the relative poverty rate now stands at almost a fifth, 18 per cent, against 13 per cent in the mid-1990s.
Job satisfaction has fallen to the lowest level ever recorded by the British Social Attitudes survey. Among the young, the mood is darker still — separate polling shows most believe that talent and hard work will not carry everyone as far as they deserve. More than one in ten young workers are on zero-hours contracts. For some that flexibility is genuinely welcome and can act as a launchpad; employers’ groups are quick to make the point. Yet across a quarter-century of gig economy expansion, Britain’s Neet rate has dipped below 10 per cent only once.
The health consequences are well documented. Nearly a million people in Britain report work-related stress, depression or anxiety, and those in poor-quality employment are up to three times more likely to exit the workforce than those in the best positions. For the growing number of young people already managing mental health difficulties, the prospect of entering such a labour market is genuinely forbidding.
Milburn’s contention is that participation remains unequivocally the right objective, and that with sufficient support the barriers can be dismantled. A job, on this reading, beats a life spent doomscrolling in a bedroom: it offers structure, routine, social connection, status and, one hopes, a measure of financial security. Unemployment, by contrast, is ruinous for wellbeing and for the wallet. Those who reach 24 without ever having worked stand to lose as much as £300,000 in lifetime earnings, even if they later re-enter the labour market successfully.
The appetite is plainly there. Only 4 per cent of working-age adults say they would ideally prefer not to work at all; among the under-25s that figure falls to 2 per cent.
Why it Matters
Britain’s youth jobs crisis is not a story about feckless teenagers or an overgenerous safety net — it is a story about an economy that has stopped building ladders. Benefit conditionality and a decade-long overhaul of the state may move the dial at the margins, but they cannot conjure the entry-level roles that have quietly vanished, nor improve the quality of the insecure work that has replaced them. If Milburn’s report becomes an exercise in squeezing the young while employers continue to demand experience for jobs designed to provide it, the social contract will fray further and the costs — fiscal, economic and human — will compound for decades. The government has a decision to make. So, too, does every boardroom in the country.

