**
In a concerning shift for healthcare in New York City, twelve nurses at Montefiore Hospital have been laid off as part of an initiative to replace their roles with AI-driven software. This decision has ignited discussions about the implications of artificial intelligence in patient care and raised alarms among healthcare professionals and patients alike about the quality of care that could be compromised.
An Unsettling Transition
Marilyn Shuler, a nurse with an impressive 39-year tenure at Montefiore, is among those affected. Known for her expertise in utilisation review, Shuler played a crucial role in interpreting patient charts and liaising with insurance providers. Yet, after nearly four decades of dedicated service, she, along with eleven colleagues, received notifications of their impending layoffs on July 10, 2026.
Shuler expressed her dismay at the situation: “I’ve always taken so much pride in the organisation I’ve worked for all these years, and just to be treated this way is disrespectful and disheartening.” Her sentiments resonate with many in the nursing community, who share her concerns about the implications of AI on their profession.
Union Response and Concerns
The New York State Nurses Association (NYSNA), which represents the affected workers, has voiced strong opposition to the layoffs, asserting that they violate a newly negotiated contract aimed at safeguarding jobs against AI encroachment. National Nurses United (NNU), the parent organisation of NYSNA, has been vocal about the risks posed by unregulated AI in healthcare settings. Jamie Brown, president of NNU, highlighted the ongoing struggle nurses face against the trend of automation that jeopardises patient care and staffing levels.
“The nurses at Montefiore have been at the forefront of battling hospital employers who are eager to introduce untested AI into patient care,” Brown stated. “Nurses know from experience that these employers will seize every opportunity to cut costs at the expense of care quality.”
Shaiju Kalathil, a fellow nurse and union executive committee member, echoed these sentiments: “We are outraged about these layoffs because these dedicated nurses are being replaced by AI. This is a violation of the contract that we recently won by going on strike. It should concern every practitioner and patient who cares about the future of healthcare and the quality of care they receive.”
The Impact of AI on Healthcare
The layoffs at Montefiore come on the heels of a significant nurses’ strike in January 2026, which resulted in new union contracts designed to protect jobs from AI displacement. Despite these agreements, Shuler and her colleagues found the workflow altered drastically upon their return to work, with no prior notice or explanation from management.
After raising their concerns with the union, they were met with silence until they received their layoff notices. “We were shocked and definitely disappointed because we repeatedly asked for transparency,” Shuler said, highlighting the lack of communication from the hospital administration.
Shuler’s role often involves intricate communications regarding medication adjustments and discharge planning—tasks she believes AI cannot effectively manage. “AI should be a tool used in conjunction with the clinical expert, not to replace,” she asserted. “We’re not against technology; there are several advances in healthcare utilizing it. The issue is with new tech without evidence.”
In response to the uproar, Montefiore Hospital has stated that the technology in question is applied in a non-clinical programme and has described the claims from NYSNA as “inaccurate and misleading.” Joe Solmonese, the senior vice-president for government relations at Montefiore, emphasised the hospital’s commitment to investing in new technology to enhance patient outcomes.
Why it Matters
The situation at Montefiore Hospital is a critical flashpoint in the ongoing dialogue about the role of technology in healthcare. The potential for AI to improve efficiency and streamline processes is undeniable, but the human element of nursing—compassion, judgement, and nuanced communication—remains irreplaceable. As healthcare institutions navigate the integration of AI, it is vital to prioritise patient care and uphold the standards that ensure quality service. The implications of these layoffs extend beyond individual nurses; they raise fundamental questions about the future of healthcare and the delicate balance between innovation and the essential human touch in medical practice.