**
In a remarkable show of solidarity, parents and students have taken a stand against perceived draconian measures implemented by the Athena Learning Trust across schools in Cornwall and Devon. Their efforts culminated in an announcement last month that the trust would disband, acknowledging the need for a fundamental shift in its approach to education. This story highlights the struggles faced by families and the profound impact that school policies can have on the well-being of children.
A Culture of Fear
The case of 14-year-old Amelia, a student at Camborne Science and International Academy, has brought attention to the strict regulations imposed by the Athena Learning Trust. In an effort to avoid disciplinary action, Amelia began to forgo drinking water at school, fearing that needing the toilet during class would draw reprimand. Her mother, Kayley, attributes Amelia’s serious health issues to these policies, which limit bathroom access during lessons.
These restrictions, instituted after Athena took control of the school in January 2024, had dire consequences, leading Amelia to suffer from kidney infections due to dehydration. Kayley describes the distress her daughter experienced, saying, “She’s now on antibiotics, she’s had water infections, and she has scarring on her kidneys because of this.”
Amelia’s situation is not an isolated incident. The concerns raised by her family echo those of many others who have been adversely affected by the strict policies enforced by Athena.
Community Response and Collective Action
The response from the community has been a resounding call for change. A collective of parents, including Kayley, has mobilised public protests, town hall meetings, and online petitions to challenge the trust’s policies. Their advocacy has garnered the support of local politicians, amplifying their voices in demanding a more compassionate approach to education.
After extensive feedback from parents and students, Athena announced plans to disband and transfer its schools to other trusts. The trust stated that it had “listened carefully to feedback” and recognised “the clear need for change.” This shift in policy is a direct result of persistent community engagement and advocacy.
Voices from Within the Schools
Interviews with former teachers and students reveal a concerning atmosphere within Athena’s schools, characterised by an “authoritarian” and “cruel” environment. One student with ADHD expressed their anxiety about making mistakes, stating, “You’re constantly scared you’re going to do something wrong.” Former teachers, like Brian Maywood, have echoed these sentiments, describing the treatment of students as oppressive and akin to a “dictatorship.”
The disciplinary measures employed by Athena included a two-strike policy, where students could be sent to “reflection” rooms for minor infractions, a practice that provoked significant concern among parents. Reports indicated that Launceston College alone recorded approximately 1,000 cases of students being sent to these reflection rooms each month, illustrating the scale of the issue.
Special Educational Needs: A Disproportionate Impact
Parents of children with special educational needs have raised alarm over how Athena’s stringent policies disproportionately affect their children. April, whose son Jack has special educational needs, highlighted the challenges he faced in such an inflexible environment, saying, “Just to look out the window to refocus, that’s not harming any of the other children…but that’s enough to be sent out.” The suspension rates at Ilfracombe Academy, where Jack was enrolled, were reported to be five times higher than the national average, further indicating the systemic issues at play.
Concerns were also voiced at town hall meetings, where many parents expressed their frustration at how children with disabilities were treated, often labelled as “defiant” rather than accommodated for their specific needs.
The Path Forward
With Athena’s announcement to disband and the Department for Education’s engagement in oversight, there is hope for a more inclusive and supportive educational environment. The Department described the allegations against Athena as “serious and concerning,” affirming their commitment to ensuring a reasonable and proportionate approach to pupil behaviour.
Bethany, a former student, summarised the widespread sentiment, stating, “They need to change the way that they’re thinking they can teach students as a one-size-fits-all.”
Why it Matters
The collective action by parents and students in Cornwall and Devon underscores the critical importance of advocating for compassionate and equitable educational policies. As schools across England grapple with issues of discipline and student well-being, the outcome of this community’s fight serves as a powerful reminder of the need for accountability and responsiveness in education. The voices of those directly affected are invaluable in shaping a future where every student feels safe, respected, and able to thrive.
