The Predator, the Presenter and the Price of Prime-Time Justice

Ben Thompson, Culture Editor
8 Min Read
⏱️ 6 min read

The pillory has gone digital. In Lance Oppenheim’s Primetime, Robert Pattinson embodies Chris Hansen with a slick, predatory charm, delivering the film’s thesis in a single, chilling line: “There used to be a pillory in every village. Now, there’s a television in every living room.” The film, released in the US this week and arriving on UK screens on 30 October, dissects the phenomenon of To Catch a Predator, the Dateline NBC juggernaut that turned the sting operation into appointment viewing. But behind the swagger and the catchphrases—“Have a seat”—lies a far messier collision of journalism, vigilantism and ratings hunger that still defines how we consume true crime today.

The Architecture of a Sting

Before the cameras rolled in the McMansions of suburbia, the infrastructure was already in place. Xavier Von Erck’s volunteer collective, Perverted Justice, was the engine room. Operating from chat rooms, their operatives—screen names like Frag and Del Harvey—posed as children, waiting for adults to make the first move. The model was proven at a local level before the networks came calling. In a single week of early 2004, CBS’s *60 Minutes II*, ABC’s Primetime Live and NBC’s Dateline all knocked on Von Erck’s door.

He turned down ABC immediately. Their crime? A national news producer for ABC News had been caught in Perverted Justice’s very first sting in Milwaukee. The network kept him on staff. “So obviously I wasn’t going to work with Primetime Live,” Von Erck recalls via email. NBC got the nod, and a formula was born: decoy actors, hidden cameras, a waiting SWAT team and Hansen, the avatar of televised retribution.

By the 2006–07 season, the show was pulling an average of 7 million viewers an episode. It wasn’t just news; it was theatre. David Osit, director of the 2025 documentary Predators, puts it bluntly. “The show was sordid and creepy and amusing… you could identify with the schadenfreude of watching these men have the worst day of their lives. In our deepest hearts we are voyeurs and we enjoy discomfort from a safe vantage point.”

The Body Count

The machine broke in Murphy, Texas. Bill Conradt, an assistant district attorney in Rockwall County, engaged with a decoy posing as a 13-year-old boy. He didn’t show up at the sting house. So the operation came to him. As a local SWAT team breached his front door, with the Dateline crew filming from the pavement, Conradt took his own life.

The Body Count

The fallout was immediate. A lawsuit settled out of court. Investigations by ABC’s *20/20* and a searing Esquire piece by Luke Dittrich—Tonight on Dateline This Man Will Die—exposed the blurred lines between law enforcement and entertainment. By 2008, To Catch a Predator was cancelled. But the template had already metastasised.

Years earlier, Kentucky Attorney General Greg Stumbo had run his own state-led stings with Perverted Justice. More than 20 arrests. Firefighters. University teachers. “People that you just walk around and see every day on the street,” Stumbo says. He makes no apologies for the spectacle. “The talk was, ‘Don’t go to Kentucky. They’ll catch you if you go to Kentucky.’ That’s what we wanted the talk to be.”

Asked about entrapment, he is unmoved. “Nobody ever came to me and said that and it wouldn’t do any good if they did… I have no sympathy for them.”

The Operator and the Image

Von Erck is fiercely proprietary about the legacy. He claims over 600 convictions, a 99.1% conviction rate, and statutory changes in all 50 states. He insists his volunteers never initiated contact. “It is quite a silly notion to believe that someone can be ‘induced’ to want to sexually assault a 10-15 year old. It requires a specific predilection.”

He speaks with the precision of a man who has litigated his reputation in the court of public opinion for two decades. “Without my organization, there was no To Catch a Predator possible at that time,” he says. “It would have been a tall reporter standing inside of a house interviewing no one.”

That ownership fuels his hostility toward Primetime. He accuses Oppenheim of “absurdly inaccurate” invention—scenes, opinions, locations, all fabricated. “It feels like an oddly and purposely malicious portrayal… they are using my legal name and semi-likeness while completely inventing every opinion, statement, act and physical location.”

The Guardian approached Oppenheim and Dittrich for comment. No response. Hansen, meanwhile, has been vocal. He calls the film an “insult” and “identity theft,” suggesting Denis Leary would have been better casting. Yet, in a move of pure brand synergy, he has bought pre-roll advertising for his true-crime streaming network, TruBlu, to run before Primetime screenings. Osit calls it “characteristically shrewd.”

The Mirror Cracks

Osit admires Hansen’s charisma but questions the endpoint. “If Chris was interested in ending child predation, the investigations wouldn’t still be going on,” he observes. “That’s not what we’re doing here.”

The Mirror Cracks

The deeper discomfort, Osit argues, isn’t about Hansen’s motives. It’s about ours. “The more interesting question than who is Chris is who are we? Why do we enjoy this show? What do we get out of the show?”

He traces a line from the sexualisation of teenage girls in mainstream culture to the mechanics of the sting: adults pretending to be children, luring men who are pretending to be something else. “This is a world that we helped create as a society… those are questions that a movie is not going to deal with.”

Why it Matters

Primetime arrives not as a eulogy for a cancelled show, but as a diagnostic scan for a culture that has only accelerated the commodification of justice. The pillory is now algorithmic; the living room is infinite scroll. We have accepted that certain offenders forfeit not just their liberty, but their humanity—fair game for content, for clicks, for the performative outrage that fuels the attention economy. Oppenheim’s film, and the furious reaction it has provoked from the very architects of the format, forces a confrontation with the uncomfortable truth that the line between exposing a predator and becoming one—feeding on vulnerability for profit—is perilously thin. The ratings are still the point.

Share This Article
Ben Thompson is a cultural commentator and arts journalist who has written extensively on film, television, music, and the creative industries. With a background in film studies from Bristol University, he spent five years as a culture writer at The Guardian before joining The Update Desk. He hosts a popular podcast exploring the intersection of art and society.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2026 The Update Desk. All rights reserved.
Terms of Service Privacy Policy