**
In the wake of a significant corruption investigation involving several officers from the Toronto Police Service’s 12 Division, a troubling history of data breaches has come to light. Over the past eight years, the division has recorded multiple instances of unlawful access to police databases, leading to disciplinary actions against officers. This unsettling trend raises serious questions about oversight and accountability within the force, particularly as the implications of the ongoing Project South investigation unfold.
A Troubling Record of Breaches
According to a detailed analysis by The Globe and Mail, four constables from the 12 Division faced sanctions for database misuse prior to the recent arrests connected to Project South. This number represents nearly one-third of all cases within the Toronto Police Service (TPS) that have resulted in police act convictions for similar breaches since 2018. These police act charges, which address severe misconduct, are generally internal matters and do not typically lead to criminal prosecution.
Adding to the concerns, one officer from the division, Constable Ricardo Gomez, has been criminally convicted for repeatedly leaking sensitive information to an individual with a criminal background. His misconduct was unveiled after police seized the offender’s phone, revealing a disturbing exchange of confidential data. Gomez is currently appealing his sentence, which includes six months of house arrest.
The Context of Project South
The Project South investigation emerged following an alleged assassination attempt on a corrections officer, prompting inquiries that traced back to TPS constable Timothy Barnhardt. Investigators alleged that Barnhardt used police databases to leak information that ultimately facilitated the attack. Seven officers from the TPS have been charged under this expansive probe, with three of them, including Barnhardt, affiliated with the 12 Division.
While the misconduct charges against these officers remain untested in court, the nature of their alleged infractions mirrors the data breaches identified in prior cases. The investigation, led by York Regional Police, is one of the largest police corruption operations in Canadian history, underscoring the gravity of the situation.
Disciplinary Actions and Patterns of Misconduct
The Globe’s examination of TPS disciplinary records reveals a pattern of improper database access among officers from 12 Division. Various infractions include unauthorized queries related to personal relationships and the tracking of individuals without legitimate police business. Most of these cases resulted in minor penalties, often just a few days’ pay docked.
For instance, Constable Alison Gaudino admitted to insubordination after conducting searches on databases for personal reasons, including queries on individuals she had relationships with. Similarly, Constable Timothy Price faced multiple charges of improper database access, culminating in a severe penalty of eight days’ pay due to the recurrence of his misconduct.
Clayton Campbell, president of the Toronto Police Association, noted that database breaches are common disciplinary issues, emphasising the necessity of context in determining the severity of each case. He stated, “Not every improper access to information reaches the threshold for criminality and may not even be considered serious misconduct.”
A Provincial Call for Oversight
In response to the alarming findings from Project South, Ontario’s Inspector-General of Policing has appointed a retired judge to oversee a comprehensive review of corruption across the province’s police services. The review will focus heavily on database security, a crucial area highlighted by the transgressions associated with the 12 Division.
Toronto Police Chief Myron Demkiw has acknowledged the need for enhanced oversight but indicated that complications arise when attempting to evaluate issues at the precinct level. The Chief has committed to strengthening internal measures, including the initiation of an anti-corruption project aimed at bolstering the detection and prevention of improper database access.
Why it Matters
The ongoing scrutiny of the Toronto Police Service’s 12 Division raises profound concerns about the integrity and accountability within law enforcement. With a history of data breaches and the alarming implications of the Project South investigation, it is imperative that robust mechanisms are established to prevent such misconduct in the future. The outcomes of both the corruption probe and the provincial review will be critical in determining public trust in police services and ensuring that those sworn to protect the community uphold the highest ethical standards.
