UBC Provost Testifies in Landmark Defamation Trial Over Steven Galloway Suspension

Nathaniel Iron, Indigenous Affairs Correspondent
7 Min Read
⏱️ 5 min read

The former dean of arts at the University of British Columbia has become the first senior university official to take the stand in the long-running defamation trial involving former creative writing professor Steven Galloway, revealing the internal deliberations that led to his highly publicised suspension in 2015.

Gage Averill, now UBC’s provost and vice-president academic, testified on Friday that he was travelling when the crisis first erupted and played only a minor role in drafting the official statement that announced Galloway’s removal from his position as chair of the creative writing programme. His testimony provides a rare, firsthand account of the administrative scramble to manage a burgeoning scandal that would come to define a pivotal moment in Canadian literary culture.

The Testimony of a Key Player

Averill, who was subpoenaed to testify, is the only major decision-maker from the university to appear in court in a case that has stretched on for more than a decade. He told the provincial Supreme Court that he was flying to Ottawa when a faculty member contacted him on a Sunday night in November 2015, alerting him to an emergency off-campus meeting of creative writing colleagues.

The meeting had been convened to discuss the explosive allegations of sexual assault levelled against Galloway by a woman known only as A.B., whose identity is protected by a publication ban. The court heard that Averill was read an email from fellow professor Annabel Lyon, who wrote: “Our first priority and primary concern is that Steve take a leave immediately so the students will feel the department is a safe environment.”

Averill confirmed that more than half a dozen administrators collaborated on the November 2015 statement. He testified that the document was deliberately edited to remove any mention of sexual violence, a change made at the behest of the university’s privacy expert. Despite this sanitisation, the statement’s reference to “serious allegations” was enough to ignite a media firestorm.

A Public Relations Crisis in the #MeToo Era

The court heard how a small group of UBC administrators worked frantically over three days to craft a message that would reassure concerned faculty and students while respecting Galloway’s privacy rights. The university’s decision to publicly announce the suspension was unprecedented. When asked by A.B.’s lawyer, Sydney Gomez, if he had ever witnessed such a public suspension during his long tenure, Averill replied, “I don’t think so.”

A Public Relations Crisis in the #MeToo Era

The administrators believed at the time that A.B. intended to go public with her allegations on social media, which influenced their decision to be more explicit than usual. Averill testified that this belief led the school to go “further than we usually do addressing that to make sure that people understood an impartial investigation would be pursued.”

The fallout was immediate and intense. Four days after the suspension letter was published, Averill and his colleagues discussed deleting it from the internet because Galloway’s union, the Faculty Association, was incensed. Lawyer Daniel Burnett, representing Galloway, asserted that “there was considerable concern expressed by the Faculty Association for Mr. Galloway’s privacy.”

Galloway, a bestselling author, filed his lawsuit in 2018 against nearly two dozen defendants. He claims that the allegations by A.B., and their repetition online by three other women, ruined his reputation, cost him his job, and destroyed his personal life. He was never charged with a crime but was fired in June 2016.

A.B. is not testifying in the trial. At its outset, one of her lawyers informed the court that she was withdrawing her defences of truth and fair comment, though she denies spreading lies about Galloway, with whom she had a two-year affair. Her legal team has stated that she attempted suicide twice due to the stress of the ordeal.

Shortly after the suspension, UBC commissioned an investigation led by former Supreme Court justice Mary Ellen Boyd. In 2016, Boyd concluded that, on a balance of probabilities, it could not be established that Galloway committed sexual assault or assault. However, she did find that he had sexually harassed A.B. and committed other misconduct.

Before Averill took the stand, lawyers for both Galloway and A.B. argued over the scope of his testimony. Justice Neena Sharma ultimately ruled to narrow the evidence he could provide, limiting the questions about other factors that may have influenced the university’s decision. With testimony now complete, closing arguments are scheduled to begin in the last week of November.

Why it Matters

This trial is more than a personal dispute; it is a landmark case examining the intersection of institutional power, reputation, and justice in the #MeToo era. The testimony of a senior UBC official sheds light on the often opaque and high-pressure decision-making processes of universities when faced with allegations of sexual misconduct. It raises critical questions about the balance between protecting the rights of the accused and the safety of the community, the role of public relations in crisis management, and the long-term consequences for all parties involved. For the Canadian literary community and beyond, the outcome of this case will have a lasting impact on how institutions navigate similar crises and how the public perceives the fairness of such processes.

Why it Matters
Share This Article
Amplifying Indigenous voices and reporting on reconciliation and rights.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2026 The Update Desk. All rights reserved.
Terms of Service Privacy Policy