MPs have accused the government of improvising its approach to China, warning that ministers are making critical decisions without a coherent strategy. The Business, Innovation, Science and Trade Committee said the lack of consistency is heightening national security risks and leaving UK businesses unable to plan for the future.
Committee condemns ‘inconsistent’ decision-making
The cross-party committee found that successive administrations have failed to reassure the public that adequate measures are in place to defend UK national security and economic resilience. In its report, MPs described government decision-making on China as characterised by “inconsistency”.
Committee chair Liam Byrne, the Labour MP, was direct in his assessment. “Britain’s businesses cannot plan for the future when the government keeps making up its China policy as it goes along,” he said. “Ministers promised clarity and consistency. Instead, we have opportunities missed, risks unmanaged and decisions left until the eleventh hour.”
Byrne added that Britain must shape its own relationship with China, or risk having that relationship shaped for it in Washington or Beijing.
The findings follow an audit of the UK-China relationship carried out last year. The government has declined to publish the document in full, citing classified information. Sir Keir Starmer, the former prime minister, had sought closer ties with Beijing, arguing that London could not afford to ignore economic opportunities while insisting this should not come at the expense of national security. His successor, Andy Burnham, has yet to set out his own position on relations with China.
Security warnings over connected technology
MPs are urging ministers to block the transfer of sensitive data to China and to impose a ban on connected technology devices being used in critical national infrastructure. The committee warned that “low-cost” Chinese connected technology has become widespread across the UK, accusing the government of prioritising “diplomatic politeness over the UK’s national security” in this area.

Universities, the report said, should also receive faster advice when conducting research with Chinese bodies.
The committee called for an end to imports made using forced labour and proposed the creation of “red” and “green” zones to define clearly where trade and investment would be encouraged and which areas would be off limits. It also advised preparing tariffs that could be imposed if China continues to subsidise its industries or fails to offer “fully reciprocal” market access.
Calls for clearer rules for business
The unpredictability of Whitehall’s approach, MPs said, has directly hindered the ability of British companies to trade with the superpower. Businesses need clear rules, the committee argued, rather than shifting guidance that leaves exporters and investors guessing.
The report urged the government to insist on fair trade with China and to provide businesses with the regulatory certainty they need to operate. Without it, the committee warned, UK firms remain exposed to sudden policy shifts and geopolitical pressure.
Government insists its approach is stable
The business department rejected the committee’s conclusions. A spokesperson said the UK’s approach to China is consistent, built on co-operation where possible and challenge where necessary.

“We have placed our relationship on a more stable, balanced, long-term footing
