A BBC investigation has revealed that more than a dozen universities in England have been presenting student loan repayment scenarios based exclusively on below-average earnings, prompting accusations of systemic misinformation from the chair of the Treasury Committee. The findings raise fresh questions about the transparency of the Plan 5 system, under which graduates repay 9 per cent of earnings above £25,000 for up to 40 years.
The Scale of the Problem
Analysis of publicly available information across more than 110 university websites uncovered a pattern of worked examples that cluster well below the UK average full-time salary of £39,039. Twelve institutions — including the University of Gloucestershire, the University of Birmingham, and Manchester Metropolitan University — provided illustrations capped at salaries ranging from £26,000 to £35,000. At the University of Gloucestershire, a £26,000 salary was shown to trigger a monthly repayment of just £7.47. Northumbria University and the University of Huddersfield used a £35,000 benchmark, resulting in a £75 monthly deduction.
The Department for Education’s own guidance mirrors this tendency. Its website offers repayment illustrations for older loan plans only up to £38,400 and provides no real-world examples for Plan 5 borrowers at all. The omission is significant: a graduate earning £30,000 repays £37.50 a month, but at £100,000 that figure jumps to £562.50. Without higher-earning scenarios, prospective students cannot model the true trajectory of their financial obligations.
‘Cost of a Coffee’ Comparisons Criticised
Dame Meg Hillier, who chaired a Treasury Committee inquiry into student loans earlier this year, described the framing as “misleading”. She singled out a since-removed claim on Northumbria’s website that £75 monthly repayments amounted to “less than the cost of a daily coffee”. The comparison echoes language the committee previously condemned: its report found the DfE had been “mis-selling” Plan 2 loans by likening repayments to £30-a-month phone contracts.

“Universities have a responsibility to the young people they’re taking on board for the three or four years of their degree,” Dame Meg said. “The DfE should be taking the lead by reflecting repayments for higher earners.” Lewis Wilson of the National Union of Students went further, arguing that if this were any other financial product, the omissions “would have crossed the line into mis-selling”.
Factual Errors Compound Confusion
Beyond selective salary examples, the BBC found outright inaccuracies on several sites. The University of Exeter stated Plan 5 loans were written off a decade earlier than the actual 40-year term. Royal Holloway and Edge Hill University listed incorrect repayment thresholds. Harper Adams University told English students they were still on Plan 2. All four institutions have since corrected their pages after being contacted.
Megan Russon, a 21-year-old tax accountant from Cannock, illustrates the real-world stakes. She graduated from the University of Birmingham with roughly £62,000 in debt and a starting salary of £29,000 — repaying about £30 a month. But she expects to earn £50,000 once chartered, pushing her repayments to nearly £187 monthly. “At open days, universities gave examples between £25,000 and £45,000 and said we wouldn’t even notice the repayments,” she said. “When I started realising the salaries I’d actually be on, I realised this is going to impact me quite a lot.”
Regulatory Response and Next Steps
The DfE has committed to reviewing its published information in line with the Treasury Committee’s recommendations and says it is working with universities to ensure clarity. Several institutions — including Gloucestershire, Birmingham, and Harper Adams — have already updated their websites. Others, such as Manchester Metropolitan and the University of Wolverhampton, say their examples were illustrative and will be reviewed. The Open University defended its lower benchmarks as reflective of its student demographic but acknowledged many go on to earn “significantly more”. Northumbria noted its £35,000 figure aligned with North East averages but pledged further review.

Why it Matters
The student loan system in England functions as a graduate tax in all but name, yet it is marketed and explained using the language of conventional debt — with all the psychological weight that carries. By consistently anchoring repayment illustrations to below-average earnings, universities and the government alike deprive applicants of the data needed to make informed decisions about their financial futures. This is not merely an administrative oversight; it is a structural asymmetry in information that disadvantages the very cohort the system claims to serve. Until repayment modelling reflects the full spectrum of graduate outcomes — from the modest to the high — the promise of “clear and accurate information” remains unfulfilled.
